II Arbitrarily Large Data

    8 Lists

      8.1 Creating Lists

      8.2 What Is '(), What Is cons

      8.3 Programming with Lists

      8.4 Computing with Lists

    9 Designing with Self-Referential Data Definitions

      9.1 Finger Exercises: Lists

      9.2 Non-empty Lists

      9.3 Natural Numbers

      9.4 Russian Dolls

      9.5 Lists and World

      9.6 A Note on Lists and Sets

    10 More on Lists

      10.1 Functions that Produce Lists

      10.2 Structures in Lists

      10.3 Lists in Lists, Files

      10.4 A Graphical Editor, Revisited

    11 Design by Composition

      11.1 The list Function

      11.2 Composing Functions

      11.3 Auxiliary Functions that Recur

      11.4 Auxiliary Functions that Generalize

    12 Projects: Lists

      12.1 Real-World Data: Dictionaries

      12.2 Real-World Data: iTunes

      12.3 Word Games, Composition Illustrated

      12.4 Word Games, the Heart of the Problem

      12.5 Feeding Worms

      12.6 Simple Tetris

      12.7 Full Space War

      12.8 Finite State Machines

    13 Summary

Every data definition in Fixed-Size Data describes data of a fixed size. To us, Boolean values, numbers, strings, and images are atomic; computer scientists say they have a size of one unit. With a structure, you compose a fixed number of pieces of data. Even if you use the language of data definitions to create deeply nested structures, you always know the exact number of atomic pieces of data in any specific instance. Many programming problems, however, deal with an undetermined number of pieces of information that must be processed as one piece of data. For example, one program may have to compute the average of a bunch of numbers and another may have to keep track of an arbitrary number of objects in an interactive game. Regardless, it is impossible with your knowledge to formulate a data definition that can represent this kind of information as data.

This part revises the language of data definitions so that it becomes possible to describe data of (finite but) arbitrary size. For a concrete illustration, the first half of this part deals with lists, a form of data that appears in most modern programming languages. In parallel with the extended language of data definitions, this part also revises the design recipe to cope with such data definitions. The latter chapters demonstrate how these data definitions and the revised design recipe work in a variety of contexts.

8 Lists

You have probably not encountered self-referential definitions before. Your English teachers certainly stay away from these, and many mathematics courses are vague when it comes to such definitions. Programmers cannot afford to be vague. Their work requires precision. While a definition may in general contain several references to itself, this chapter presents useful examples that need just one, starting with the one for lists.

The introduction of lists also spices up the kind of applications we can study. While this chapter carefully builds up your intuition with examples, it also motivates the revision of the design recipe in the next chapter, which explains how to systematically create functions that deal with self-referential data definitions.

8.1 Creating Lists

All of us make lists all the time. Before we go grocery shopping, we write down a list of items we wish to purchase. Some people write down a to-do list every morning. During December, many children prepare Christmas wish lists. To plan a party, we make a list of invitees. Arranging information in the form of lists is an ubiquitous part of our life.

Given that information comes in the shape of lists, we must clearly learn how to represent such lists as BSL data. Indeed, because lists are so important, BSL comes with built-in support for creating and manipulating lists, similar to the support for Cartesian points (posn). In contrast to points, the data definition for lists is always left to you. But first things first. We start with the creation of lists.

When we form a list, we always start out with the empty list. In BSL, we represent the empty list with


which is pronounced “empty,” short for “empty list.” Like #true or 5, '() is just a constant. When we add something to a list, we construct another list; in BSL, the cons operation serves this purpose. For example,

(cons "Mercury" '())

constructs a list from the '() list and the string "Mercury". Figure 44 presents this list in the same pictorial manner we used for structures. The box for cons has two fields: first and rest. In this specific example the first field contains "Mercury" and the rest field contains '().




(cons "Mercury"



(cons "Venus"
  (cons "Mercury"



(cons "Earth"
  (cons "Venus"
    (cons "Mercury"



Figure 44: Building a list

Once we have a list with one item in it, we can construct lists with two items by using cons again. Here is one:

(cons "Venus" (cons "Mercury" '()))

And here is another:

(cons "Earth" (cons "Mercury" '()))

The middle row of figure 44 shows how you can imagine lists that contain two items. It is also a box of two fields, but this time the rest field contains a box. Indeed, it contains the box from the top row of the same figure.

Finally, we construct a list with three items:

(cons "Earth" (cons "Venus" (cons "Mercury" '())))

The last row of figure 44 illustrates the list with three items. Its rest field contains a box that contains a box again. So, as we create lists we put boxes into boxes into boxes, and so on. While this may appear strange at first glance, it is just like a set of Chinese gift boxes or a set of nested drinking cups, which we sometimes get for birthdays. The only difference is that BSL programs can nest lists much deeper than any artist could nest physical boxes.

(cons "Earth"
  (cons "Venus"
    (cons "Mercury"



Figure 45: Drawing a list

Because even good artists would have problems with drawing deeply nested structures, computer scientists resort to box-and-arrow diagrams instead. Figure 45 illustrates how to rearrange the last row of figure 44. Each cons structure becomes a separate box. If the rest field is too complex to be drawn inside of the box, we draw a bullet instead and a line with an arrow to the box that it contains. Depending on how the boxes are arranged, you get two kinds of diagrams. The first, displayed in the top row of figure 45, lists the boxes in the order in which they are created. The second, displayed in the bottom row, lists the boxes in the order in which they are consed together. Hence the second diagram immediately tells you what first would have produced when applied to the list, no matter how long the list is. For this reason, programmers prefer the second arrangement.

Exercise 129. Create BSL lists that represent
  1. a list of celestial bodies, say, at least all the planets in our solar system;

  2. a list of items for a meal, for example, steak, french fries, beans, bread, water, Brie cheese, and ice cream; and

  3. a list of colors.

Sketch some box representations of these lists, similar to those in figures 44 and 45. Which of the sketches do you like better?

You can also make lists of numbers. Here is a list with the 10 digits:
(cons 0
  (cons 1
    (cons 2
      (cons 3
        (cons 4
          (cons 5
            (cons 6
              (cons 7
                (cons 8
                  (cons 9 '()))))))))))
To build this list requires 10 list constructions and one '(). For a list of three arbitrary numbers, for example,
(cons pi
  (cons e
    (cons -22.3 '())))
we need three conses.

In general a list does not have to contain values of one kind, but may contain arbitrary values:
(cons "Robbie Round"
  (cons 3
    (cons #true
The firstThen again, if this list is supposed to represent a record with a fixed number of pieces, use a structure type instead. item of this list is a string, the second one is a number, and the last one a Boolean. You may consider this list as the representation of a personnel record with three pieces of data: the name of the employee, the number of years spent at the company, and whether the employee has health insurance through the company. Or, you could think of it as representing a virtual player in some game. Without a data definition, you just can’t know what data is all about.

Here is a first data definition that involves cons:
; A 3LON is a list of three numbers:
;   (cons Number (cons Number (cons Number '())))
; interpretation a point in 3-dimensional space
Of course, this data definition uses cons like others use constructors for structure instances, and in a sense, cons is just a special constructor. What this data definition fails to demonstrate is how to form lists of arbitrary length: lists that contain nothing, one item, two items, ten items, or perhaps 1,438,901 items.

So let’s try again:
; A List-of-names is one of:
;  '()
;  (cons String List-of-names)
; interpretation a list of invitees, by last name
Take a deep breath, read it again. This data definition is one of the most unusual definitions you have ever encountered—you have never before seen a definition that refers to itself. It isn’t even clear whether it makes sense. After all, if you had told your English teacher that “a table is a table” defines the word “table,” the most likely response would have been “Nonsense!” because a self-referential definition doesn’t explain what a word means.

In computer science and in programming, though, self-referential definitions play a central role, and with some care, such definitions actually do make sense. Here “making sense” means that we can use the data definition for what it is intended for, namely, to generate examples of data that belong to the class that is being defined or to check whether some given piece of data belongs to the defined class of data. From this perspective, the definition of List-of-names makes complete sense. At a minimum, we can generate '() as one example, using the first clause in the itemization. Given '() as an element of List-of-names, it is easy to make a second one:

(cons "Findler" '())

Here we are using a String and the only list from List-of-names to generate a piece of data according to the second clause in the itemization. With the same rule, we can generate many more lists of this kind:
(cons "Flatt" '())
(cons "Felleisen" '())
(cons "Krishnamurthi" '())
And while these lists all contain one name (represented as a String), it is actually possible to use the second line of the data definition to create lists with more names in them:

(cons "Felleisen" (cons "Findler" '()))

This piece of data belongs to List-of-names because "Felleisen" is a String and (cons "Findler" '()) is a confirmed List-of-names.

Exercise 130. Create an element of List-of-names that contains five Strings. Sketch a box representation of the list similar to those found in figure 44.

Explain why

(cons "1" (cons "2" '()))

is an element of List-of-names and why (cons 2 '()) isn’t.

Exercise 131. Provide a data definition for representing lists of Boolean values. The class contains all arbitrarily long lists of Booleans.

8.2 What Is '(), What Is cons

Let’s step back for a moment and take a close look at '() and cons. As mentioned, '() is just a constant. When compared to constants such as 5 or "this is a string", it looks more like a function name or a variable; but when compared with #true and #false, it should be easy to see that it really is just BSL’s representation for empty lists.

As for our evaluation rules, '() is a new kind of atomic value, distinct from any other kind: numbers, Booleans, strings, and so on. It also isn’t a compound value, like Posns. Indeed, '() is so unique it belongs in a class of values all by itself. As such, this class of values comes with a predicate that recognizes only '() and nothing else:
; Any -> Boolean
; is the given value '()
(define (empty? x) ...)
Like all predicates, empty? can be applied to any value from the universe of BSL values. It produces #true precisely when it is applied to '():
> (empty? '())


> (empty? 5)


> (empty? "hello world")


> (empty? (cons 1 '()))


> (empty? (make-posn 0 0))


Next we turn to cons. Everything we have seen so far suggests that cons is a constructor just like those introduced by structure type definitions. More precisely, cons appears to be the constructor for a two-field structure: the first one for any kind of value and the second one for any list-like value. The following definitions translate this idea into BSL:
(define-struct pair [left right])
; A ConsPair is a structure:
;   (make-pair Any Any).
; Any Any -> ConsPair
(define (our-cons a-value a-list)
  (make-pair a-value a-list))
The only catch is that our-cons accepts all possible BSL values for its second argument and cons doesn’t, as the following experiment validates:
> (cons 1 2)

cons:second argument must be a list, but received 1 and 2

Put differently, cons is really a checked function, the kind discussed in Itemizations and Structures, which suggests the following refinement:
; A ConsOrEmpty is one of:
;  '()
;  (make-pair Any ConsOrEmpty)
; interpretation ConsOrEmpty is the class of all lists
; Any Any -> ConsOrEmpty
(define (our-cons a-value a-list)
    [(empty? a-list) (make-pair a-value a-list)]
    [(pair? a-list) (make-pair a-value a-list)]
    [else (error "cons: second argument ...")]))

If cons is a checked constructor function, you may be wondering how to extract the pieces from the resulting structure. After all, Adding Structure says that programming with structures requires selectors. Since a cons structure has two fields, there are two selectors: first and rest. They are also easily defined in terms of our pair structure:
; ConsOrEmpty -> Any
; extracts the left part of the given pair
(define (our-first a-list)
  (if (empty? a-list)
      (error 'our-first "...")
      (pair-left a-list)))
Stop! Define our-rest.

If your program can access the structure type definition for pair, it is easy to create pairs that don’t contain '() or another pair in the right field. Whether such bad instances are created intentionally or accidentally, they tend to break functions and programs in strange ways. BSL therefore hides the actual structure type definition for cons to avoid these problems. Local Definitions demonstrates one way that your programs can hide such definitions, too, but for now, you don’t need this power.



a special value, mostly to represent the empty list



a predicate to recognize '() and nothing else



a checked constructor to create two-field instances



the selector to extract the last item added



the selector to extract the extended list



a predicate to recognize instances of cons

Figure 46: List primitives

Figure 46 summarizes this section. The key insight is that '() is a unique value and that cons is a checked constructor that produces list values. Furthermore, first, rest, and cons? are merely distinct names for the usual predicate and selectors. What this chapter teaches, then, is not a new way of creating data but a new way of formulating data definitions.

8.3 Programming with Lists

Say you’re keeping track of your friends with some list, and say the list has grown so large that you need a program to determine whether someHere we use the word “friend” in the sense of social networks, not the real world. name is on the list. To make this idea concrete, let’s state it as an exercise:

Sample Problem You are working on the contact list for some new cell phone. The phone’s owner updates and consults this list on various occasions. For now, you are assigned the task of designing a function that consumes this list of contacts and determines whether it contains the name “Flatt.”

Once we have a solution to this sample problem, we will generalize it to a function that finds any name on a list.

The data definition for List-of-names from the preceding is appropriate for representing the list of names that the function is to search. Next we turn to the header material:
; List-of-names -> Boolean
; determines whether "Flatt" is on a-list-of-names
(define (contains-flatt? a-list-of-names)
While a-list-of-names is a good name for the list of names that the function consumes, it is a mouthful and we therefore shorten it to alon.

Following the general design recipe, we next make up some examples that illustrate the purpose of the function. First, we determine the output for the simplest input: '(). Since this list does not contain any strings, it certainly does not contain "Flatt":

(check-expect (contains-flatt? '()) #false)

Then we consider lists with a single item. Here are two examples:
(check-expect (contains-flatt? (cons "Find" '()))
(check-expect (contains-flatt? (cons "Flatt" '()))
In the first case, the answer is #false because the single item on the list is not "Flatt"; in the second case, the single item is "Flatt", so the answer is #true. Finally, here is a more general example:
    (cons "A" (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '()))))
Again, the answer case must be #true because the list contains "Flatt". Stop! Make a general example for which the answer must be #false.

Take a breath. Run the program. The header is a “dummy” definition for the function; you have some examples; they have been turned into tests; and best of all, some of them actually succeed. They succeed for the wrong reason but succeed they do. If things make sense now, read on.

The fourth step is to design a function template that matches the data definition. Since the data definition for lists of strings has two clauses, the function’s body must be a cond expression with two clauses. The two conditions determine which of the two kinds of lists the function received:
(define (contains-flatt? alon)
    [(empty? alon) ...]
    [(cons? alon) ...]))
Instead of (cons? alon), we could use else in the second clause.

We can add one more hint to the template by studying each clause of the cond expression in turn. Specifically, recall that the design recipe suggests annotating each clause with selector expressions if the corresponding class of inputs consists of compounds. In our case, we know that '() does not have compounds, so there are no components. Otherwise the list is constructed from a string and another list of strings, and we remind ourselves of this fact by adding (first alon) and (rest alon) to the template:
(define (contains-flatt? alon)
    [(empty? alon) ...]
    [(cons? alon)
     (... (first alon) ... (rest alon) ...)]))

Now it is time to switch to the programming task proper, the fifth step of our design recipe. It starts from a template and deals with each cond clause separately. If (empty? alon) is true, the input is the empty list, in which case the function must produce the result #false. In the second case, (cons? alon) is true. The annotations in the template remind us that there is a first string and then the rest of the list. So let’s consider an example that falls into this category:
(cons "A"
  (cons ...
      ... '()))
The function, like a person, must compare the first item with "Flatt". In this example, the first one is "A" and not "Flatt", so the comparison yields #false. If we had considered some other example instead, say,
(cons "Flatt"
  (cons ...
      ... '()))
the function would determine that the first item on the input is "Flatt", and would therefore respond with #true. This implies that the second line in the cond expression should contain an expression that compares the first name on the list with "Flatt":
(define (contains-flatt? alon)
    [(empty? alon) #false]
    [(cons? alon)
     (... (string=? (first alon) "Flatt")
      ... (rest alon) ...)]))
Furthermore, if the comparison yields #true, the function must produce #true. If the comparison yields #false, we are left with another list of strings: (rest alon). Clearly, the function can’t know the final answer in this case, because the answer depends on what “...” represents. Put differently, if the first item is not "Flatt", we need some way to check whether the rest of the list contains "Flatt".

Fortunately, we have contains-flatt? and it fits the bill. According to its purpose statement, it determines whether a list contains "Flatt". The statement implies that (contains-flatt? l) tells us whether the list of strings l contains "Flatt". And, in the same vein, (contains-flatt? (rest alon)) determines whether "Flatt" is a member of (rest alon), which is precisely what we need to know.

In short, the last line should be (contains-flatt? (rest alon)):
; List-of-names -> Boolean
(define (contains-flatt? alon)
    [(empty? alon) #false]
    [(cons? alon)
     (... (string=? (first alon) "Flatt") ...
      ... (contains-flatt? (rest alon)) ...)]))
The trick is now to combine the values of the two expressions in the appropriate manner. As mentioned, if the first expression yields #true, there is no need to search the rest of the list; if it is #false, though, the second expression may still yield #true, meaning the name "Flatt" is on the rest of the list. All of this suggests that the result of (contains-flatt? alon) is #true if either the first expression in the last line or the second expression yields #true.

; List-of-names -> Boolean
; determines whether "Flatt" occurs on alon
  (contains-flatt? (cons "X" (cons "Y"  (cons "Z" '()))))
  (contains-flatt? (cons "A" (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '()))))
(define (contains-flatt? alon)
    [(empty? alon) #false]
    [(cons? alon)
     (or (string=? (first alon) "Flatt")
         (contains-flatt? (rest alon)))]))

Figure 47: Searching a list

Figure 47 then shows the complete definition. Overall it doesn’t look too different from the definitions in the first chapter of the book. It consists of a signature, a purpose statement, two examples, and a definition. The only way in which this function definition differs from anything you have seen before is the self-reference, that is, the reference to contains-flatt? in the body of the define. Then again, the data definition is self-referential, too, so in some sense the self-reference in the function shouldn’t be too surprising.

Exercise 132. Use DrRacket to run contains-flatt? in this example:
(cons "Fagan"
  (cons "Findler"
    (cons "Fisler"
      (cons "Flanagan"
        (cons "Flatt"
          (cons "Felleisen"
            (cons "Friedman" '())))))))
What answer do you expect?

Exercise 133. Here is another way of formulating the second cond clause in contains-flatt?:
... (cond
      [(string=? (first alon) "Flatt") #true]
      [else (contains-flatt? (rest alon))]) ...
Explain why this expression produces the same answers as the or expression in the version of figure 47. Which version is clearer to you? Explain.

Exercise 134. Develop the contains? function, which determines whether some given string occurs on a given list of strings.

Note BSL actually comes with member?, a function that consumes two values and checks whether the first occurs in the second, a list:
> (member? "Flatt" (cons "b" (cons "Flatt" '())))


Don’t use member? to define the contains? function.

(contains-flatt? (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))
  [(empty? (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '()))) #false]
  [(cons? (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))
    (string=? (first (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '()))) "Flatt")
    (contains-flatt? (rest (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))))])

Figure 48: Computing with lists, step 1

8.4 Computing with Lists

Since we are still using BSL, the rules of algebra—see intermezzo 1—tell us how to determine the value of expressions such as

(contains-flatt? (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))

without DrRacket. Programmers must have an intuitive understanding of how this kind of calculation works, so we step through the one for this simple example.

Figure 48 displays the first step, which uses the usual substitution rule to determine the value of an application. The result is a conditional expression because, as an algebra teacher would say, the function is defined in a step-wise fashion.

 [#false #false]
 [(cons? (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))
  (or (string=? (first (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '()))) "Flatt")
      (contains-flatt? (rest (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))))])
 [(cons? (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))
  (or (string=? (first (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '()))) "Flatt")
      (contains-flatt? (rest (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))))])
  (or (string=? (first (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '()))) "Flatt")
      (contains-flatt? (rest (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))))])
(or (string=? (first (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '()))) "Flatt")
    (contains-flatt? (rest (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))))

Figure 49: Computing with lists, step 2

The calculation is continued in figure 49. To find the correct clause of the cond expression, we must determine the value of the conditions, one by one. Since a consed list isn’t empty, the first condition’s result is #false, and we therefore eliminate the first cond clause. Finally the condition in the second clause evaluates to #true because cons? of a consed list holds.

(or (string=? "Flatt" "Flatt")
    (contains-flatt? (rest (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))))
== (or #true (contains-flatt? ...))
== #true

Figure 50: Computing with lists, step 3

From here, it is just three more steps of arithmetic to get the final result. Figure 50 displays the three steps. The first evaluates (first (cons "Flatt" ...)) to "Flatt" due to the laws for first. The second discovers that "Flatt" is a string and equal to "Flatt". The third says (or #true X) is #true regardless of what X is.

Exercise 135. Use DrRacket’s stepper to check the calculation for

(contains-flatt? (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '())))

Also use the stepper to determine the value of
  (cons "A" (cons "Flatt" (cons "C" '()))))
What happens when "Flatt" is replaced with "B"?

Exercise 136. Validate with DrRacket’s stepper
(our-first (our-cons "a" '())) == "a"
(our-rest (our-cons "a" '())) == '()
See What Is '(), What Is cons for the definitions of these functions.



Figure 51: Arrows for self-references in data definitions and templates

9 Designing with Self-Referential Data Definitions

At first glance, self-referential data definitions seem to be far more complex than those for mixed data. But, as the example of contains-flatt? shows, the six steps of the design recipe still work. Nevertheless, in this section we generalize the design recipe so that it works even better for self-referential data definitions. The new parts concern the process of discovering when a self-referential data definition is needed, deriving a template, and defining the function body:
  1. If a problem statement is about information of arbitrary size, you need a self-referential data definition to represent it. At this point, you have seen only one such class, List-of-names. The left side of figure 51 shows how to define List-of-strings in the same way. Other lists of atomic data work the same way.

    Numbers also seem to be arbitrarily large. For inexact numbers, this is an illusion. For precise integers, this is indeed the case. Dealing with integers is therefore a part of this chapter.

    For a self-referential data definition to be valid, it must satisfy two conditions. First, it must contain at least two clauses. Second, at least one of the clauses must not refer back to the class of data that is being defined. It is good practice to identify the self-references explicitly with arrows from the references in the data definition back to the term being defined; see figure 51 for an example of such an annotation.

    You must check the validity of self-referential data definitions with the creation of data examples. Start with the clause that does not refer to the data definition; continue with the other one, using the first example where the clause refers to the definition itself. For the data definition in figure 51, you thus get lists like the following three:


    by the first clause

    (cons "a" '())


    by the second clause, previous example

    (cons "b"
      (cons "a"


    by the second clause, previous example

    If it is impossible to generate examples from the data definition, it is invalid. If you can generate examples but you can’t see how to generate increasingly larger examples, the definition may not live up to its interpretation.

  2. Nothing changes about the header material: the signature, the purpose statement, and the dummy definition. When you do formulate the purpose statement, focus on what the function computes not how it goes about it, especially not how it goes through instances of the given data.

    Here is an example to make this design recipe concrete:
    ; List-of-strings -> Number
    ; counts how many strings alos contains
    (define (how-many alos)
    The purpose statement clearly states that the function just counts the strings on the given input; there is no need to think ahead about how you might formulate this idea as a BSL function.

  3. When it comes to functional examples, be sure to work through inputs that use the self-referential clause of the data definition several times. It is the best way to formulate tests that cover the entire function definition later.

    For our running example, the purpose statement almost generates functional examples by itself from the data examples:







    (cons "a" '())



    (cons "b" (cons "a" '()))



    The first row is about the empty list, and we know that empty list contains nothing. The second row is a list of one string, so 1 is the desired answer. The last row is about a list of two strings.

  4. At the core, a self-referential data definition looks like a data definition for mixed data. The development of the template can therefore proceed according to the recipe in Itemizations and Structures. Specifically, we formulate a cond expression with as many cond clauses as there are clauses in the data definition, match each recognizing condition to the corresponding clause in the data definition, and write down appropriate selector expressions in all cond lines that process compound values.




    Does the data definition distinguish among different sub-classes of data?


    Your template needs as many cond clauses as sub-classes that the data definition distinguishes.

    How do the sub-classes differ from each other?


    Use the differences to formulate a condition per clause.

    Do any of the clauses deal with structured values?


    If so, add appropriate selector expressions to the clause.

    Does the data definition use self-references?


    Formulate “natural recursions” for the template to represent the self-references of the data definition.

    If the data definition refers to some other data definition, where is this cross-reference to another data definition?


    Specialize the template for the other data definition. Refer to this template. See Designing with Itemizations, Again, steps 4 and 5 of the design recipe.

    Figure 52: How to translate a data definition into a template

    Figure 52 expresses this idea as a question-and-answer game. In the left column it states questions about the data definition for the argument, and in the right column it explains what the answer means for the construction of the template.

    If you ignore the last row and apply the first three questions to any function that consumes a List-of-strings, you arrive at this shape:
    (define (fun-for-los alos)
        [(empty? alos) ...]
          (... (first alos) ... (rest alos) ...)]))

    Recall, though, that the purpose of a template is to express the data definition as a function layout. That is, a template expresses as code what the data definition for the input expresses as a mix of English and BSL. Hence all important pieces of the data definition must find a counterpart in the template, and this guideline should also hold when a data definition is self-referential—contains an arrow from inside the definition to the term being defined. In particular, when a data definition is self-referential in the ith clause and the kth field of the structure mentioned there, the template should be self-referential in the ith cond clause and the selector expression for the kth field. For each such selector expression, add an arrow back to the function parameter. At the end, your template must have as many arrows as we have in the data definition.

    Figure 51 illustrates this idea with the template for functions that consume List-of-strings shown side by side with the data definition. Both contain one arrow that originates in the second clause—the rest field and selector, respectively—and points back to the top of the respective definitions.

    Since BSL and most programming languages are text-oriented, you must use an alternative to the arrow, namely, a self-application of the function to the appropriate selector expression:
    (define (fun-for-los alos)
        [(empty? alos) ...]
          (... (first alos) ...
           ... (fun-for-los (rest alos)) ...)]))
    We refer to a self-use of a function as recursion and in the first four parts of the book as natural recursion.

  5. For the function body we start with thoseFor the curious among our readers, the design recipe for arbitrarily large data corresponds to so-called “proofs by induction” in mathematics, and the “leap of faith” represents the use of the induction hypothesis for the inductive step of such a proof. Logic proves the validity of this proof technique with an Induction Theorem. cond lines without recursive function calls, known as base cases.The corresponding answers are typically easy to formulate or already given as examples.

    Then we deal with the self-referential cases. We start by reminding ourselves what each of the expressions in the template line computes. For the natural recursion we assume that the function already works as specified in our purpose statement. This last step is a leap of faith, but as you will see, it always works.

    The rest is then a matter of combining the various values.




    What are the answers for the non-recursive cond clauses?


    The examples should tell you which values you need here. If not, formulate appropriate examples and tests.

    What do the selector expressions in the recursive clauses compute?


    The data definitions tell you what kind of data these expressions extract, and the interpretations of the data definitions tell you what this data represents.

    What do the natural recursions compute?


    Use the purpose statement of the function to determine what the value of the recursion means, not how it computes this answer. If the purpose statement doesn’t tell you the answer, improve the purpose statement.

    How can the function combine these values to get the desired answer?


    Find a function in BSL that combines the values. Or, if that doesn’t work, make a wish for a helper function. For many functions, this last step is straightforward. The purpose, the examples, and the template together tell you which function or expression combines the available values into the proper result. We refer to this function or expression as a combinator, slightly abusing existing terminology.

    Figure 53: How to turn a template into a function definition




    So, if you are stuck here, ...


    ... arrange the examples from the third step in a table. Place the given input in the first column and the desired output in the last column. In the intermediate columns enter the values of the selector expressions and the natural recursion(s). Add examples until you see a pattern emerge that suggests a combinator.

    If the template refers to some other template, what does the auxiliary function compute?


    Consult the other function’s purpose statement and examples to determine what it computes, and assume you may use the result even if you haven’t finished the design of this helper function.

    Figure 54: Turning a template into a function, the table method

    Figure 53 formulates the first four questions and answers for this step. Let’s use this game to complete the definition of how-many. Renaming the fun-for-los template to how-many gives us this much:
    ; List-of-strings -> Number
    ; determines how many strings are on alos
    (define (how-many alos)
        [(empty? alos) ...]
         (... (first alos) ...
          ... (how-many (rest alos)) ...)]))
    As the functional examples already suggest, the answer for the base case is 0. The two expressions in the second clause compute the first item and the number of strings in (rest alos). To compute how many strings there are on all of alos, the function just needs to add 1 to the value of the latter expression:
    (define (how-many alos)
        [(empty? alos) 0]
        [else (+ (how-many (rest alos)) 1)]))

    Felix Klock suggested this table-based approach to guessing the combinator.

    Finding the correct way to combine the values into the desired answer isn’t always as easy. Novice programmers often get stuck with this step. As figure 54 suggests, it is a good idea to arrange the functional examples into a table that also spells out the values of the expressions in the template. Figure 55 shows what this table looks like for our how-many example. The left-most column lists the sample inputs, while the right-most column contains the desired answers for these inputs. The three columns in between show the values of the template expressions: (first alos), (rest alos), and (how-many (rest alos)), which is the natural recursion. If you stare at this table long enough, you recognize that the result column is always one more than the values in the natural recursion column. You may thus guess that

    (+ (how-many (rest alos)) 1)

    is the expression that computes the desired result. Since DrRacket is fast at checking these kinds of guesses, plug it in and click RUN. If the examples-turned-into-tests pass, think through the expression to convince yourself it works for all lists; otherwise add more example rows to the table until you have a different idea.

    The table also points out that some selector expressions in the template are possibly irrelevant for the actual definition. Here (first alos) is not needed to compute the final answer—which is quite a contrast to contains-flatt?, which uses both expressions from the template.

    As you work your way through the rest of this book, keep in mind that, in many cases, the combination step can be expressed with BSL’s primitives, say, +, and, or cons. In some cases, though, you may have to make a wish, that is, design an auxiliary function. Finally, in yet other cases, you may need nested conditions.

  6. Finally, make sure to turn all examples into tests, that these tests pass, and that running them covers all the pieces of the function.

    Here are our examples for how-many turned into tests:
    (check-expect (how-many '()) 0)
    (check-expect (how-many (cons "a" '())) 1)
      (how-many (cons "b" (cons "a" '()))) 2)
    Remember, it is best to formulate examples directly as tests, and BSL allows this. Doing so also helps if you need to resort to the table-based guessing approach of the preceding step.







  (rest alos))


(cons "a"








(cons "b"
  (cons "a"




(cons "a"




(cons "x"
  (cons "b"
    (cons "a"




(cons "b"
  (cons "a"





Figure 55: Tabulating arguments, intermediate values, and results

Figure 56 summarizes the design recipe of this section in a tabular format. The first column names the steps of the design recipe, and the second the expected results of each step. In the third column, we describe the activities that get you there.You may want to copy figure 56 onto one side of an index card and write down your favorite versions of the questions and answers for this design recipe onto the back of it. Then carry it with you for future reference. The figure is tailored to the kind of self-referential list definitions we use in this chapter. As always, practice helps you master the process, so we strongly recommend that you tackle the following exercises, which ask you to apply the recipe to several kinds of examples.






problem analysis


data definition


Develop a data representation for the information; create examples for specific items of information and interpret data as information; identify self-references.



signature; purpose; dummy definition


Write down a signature using defined names; formulate a concise purpose statement; create a dummy function that produces a constant value from the specified range.



examples and tests


Work through several examples, at least one per clause in the data definition.



function template


Translate the data definition into a template: one cond clause per data clause; selectors where the condition identifies a structure; one natural recursion per self-reference.



full-fledged definition


Find a function that combines the values of the expressions in the cond clauses into the expected answer.



validated tests


Turn them into check-expect tests and run them.

Figure 56: Designing a function for self-referential data

9.1 Finger Exercises: Lists

Exercise 137. Compare the template for contains-flatt? with the one for how-many. Ignoring the function name, they are the same. Explain the similarity.

Exercise 138. Here is a data definition for representing sequences of amounts of money:
; A List-of-amounts is one of:
;  '()
;  (cons PositiveNumber List-of-amounts)
Create some examples to make sure you understand the data definition. Also add an arrow for the self-reference.

Design the sum function, which consumes a List-of-amounts and computes the sum of the amounts. Use DrRacket’s stepper to see how (sum l) works for a short list l in List-of-amounts.

Exercise 139. Now take a look at this data definition:
; A List-of-numbers is one of:
;  '()
;  (cons Number List-of-numbers)
Some elements of this class of data are appropriate inputs for sum from exercise 138 and some aren’t.

Design the function pos?, which consumes a List-of-numbers and determines whether all numbers are positive numbers. In other words, if (pos? l) yields #true, then l is an element of List-of-amounts. Use DrRacket’s stepper to understand how pos? works for (cons 5 '()) and (cons -1 '()).

Also design checked-sum. The function consumes a List-of-numbers. It produces their sum if the input also belongs to List-of-amounts; otherwise it signals an error. Hint Recall to use check-error.

What does sum compute for an element of List-of-numbers?

Exercise 140. Design the function all-true, which consumes a list of Boolean values and determines whether all of them are #true. In other words, if there is any #false on the list, the function produces #false.

Now design one-true, a function that consumes a list of Boolean values and determines whether at least one item on the list is #true.

Employ the table-based approach to coding. It may help with the base case. Use DrRacket’s stepper to see how these functions process the lists (cons #true '()), (cons #false '()), and (cons #true (cons #false '())).

Exercise 141. If you are asked to design the function cat, which consumes a list of strings and appends them all into one long string, you are guaranteed to end up with this partial definition:
; List-of-string -> String
; concatenates all strings in l into one long string
(check-expect (cat '()) "")
(check-expect (cat (cons "a" (cons "b" '()))) "ab")
  (cat (cons "ab" (cons "cd" (cons "ef" '()))))
(define (cat l)
    [(empty? l) ""]
    [else (... (first l) ... (cat (rest l)) ...)]))



(first l)


(rest l)


(cat (rest l))


(cat l)
(cons "a"
 (cons "b"








 (cons "cd"
   (cons "ef"









Figure 57: A table for cat

Fill in the table in figure 57. Guess a function that can create the desired result from the values computed by the sub-expressions.

Use DrRacket’s stepper to evaluate (cat (cons "a" '())).

Exercise 142. Design the ill-sized? function, which consumes a list of images loi and a positive number n. It produces the first image on loi that is not an n by n square; if it cannot find such an image, it produces #false.

Hint Use
; ImageOrFalse is one of:
;  Image
;  #false
for the result part of the signature.

9.2 Non-empty Lists

Now you know enough to use cons and to create data definitions for lists. If you solved (some of) the exercises at the end of the preceding section, you can deal with lists of various flavors of numbers, lists of Boolean values, lists of images, and so on. In this section we continue to explore what lists are and how to process them.

Let’s start with the simple-looking problem of computing the average of a list of temperatures. To simplify, we provide the data definitions:
; A List-of-temperatures is one of:
;  '()
;  (cons CTemperature List-of-temperatures)
(define ABSOLUTE0 -272)
; A CTemperature is a Number greater than ABSOLUTE0.
For our intentions, you should think of temperatures as plain numbers, but the second data definition reminds you that in reality not all numbers are temperatures and you should keep this in mind.

The header material is straightforward:
; List-of-temperatures -> Number
; computes the average temperature
(define (average alot) 0)
Making up examples for this problem is also easy, and so we just formulate one test:
  (average (cons 1 (cons 2 (cons 3 '())))) 2)
The expected result is of course the sum of the temperatures divided by the number of temperatures.

A moment’s thought tells you that the template for average should be similar to the ones we have seen so far:
(define (average alot)
    [(empty? alot) ...]
    [(cons? alot)
     (... (first alot) ...
      ... (average (rest alot)) ...)]))
The two cond clauses mirror the two clauses of the data definition; the questions distinguish empty lists from non-empty lists; and the natural recursion is needed because of the self-reference in the data definition.

It is way too difficult, however, to turn this template into a function definition. The first cond clause needs a number that represents the average of an empty collection of temperatures, but there is no such number. Similarly, the second clause demands a function that combines a temperature and an average for the remaining temperatures into a new average. Although possible, computing the average in this way is highly unnatural.

When we compute the average of temperatures, we divide their sum by their number. We said so when we formulated our trivial little example. This sentence suggests that average is a function of three tasks: summing, counting, and dividing. Our guideline from Fixed-Size Data tells us to write one function per task, and if we do so the design of average is obvious:
; List-of-temperatures -> Number
; computes the average temperature
(define (average alot)
  (/ (sum alot) (how-many alot)))
; List-of-temperatures -> Number
; adds up the temperatures on the given list
(define (sum alot) 0)
; List-of-temperatures -> Number
; counts the temperatures on the given list
(define (how-many alot) 0)
The last two function definitions are wishes, of course, for which we need to design complete definitions. Doing so is easy because how-many from above works for List-of-strings and List-of-temperatures (why?) and because the design of sum follows the same old routine:
; List-of-temperatures -> Number
; adds up the temperatures on the given list
(define (sum alot)
    [(empty? alot) 0]
    [else (+ (first alot) (sum (rest alot)))]))
Stop! Use the example for average to create one for sum and ensure that the test runs properly. Then run the tests for average.

When you read this definition of average now, it is obviously correct simply because it directly corresponds to what everyone learns about averaging in school. Still, programs run not just for us but for others. In particular, others should be able to read the signature and use the function and expect an informative answer. But, our definition of average does not work for empty lists of temperatures.

Exercise 143. Determine how average behaves in DrRacket when applied to the empty list. Then design checked-average, a function that produces an informative error message when it is applied to '().

In mathematics, we would say exercise 143 shows that average is a partial function because it raises an error for '().

An alternative solution is to inform future readers through the signature that average doesn’t work for empty lists. For that, we need a data representation for lists that excludes '(), something like this:
; An NEList-of-temperatures is one of:
;  ???
;  (cons CTemperature NEList-of-temperatures)
The question is with what we should replace “???” so that the '() list is excluded but all other lists of temperatures are still constructable. One hint is that while the empty list is the shortest list, any list of one temperature is the next shortest list. In turn, this suggests that the first clause should describe all possible lists of one temperature:
; An NEList-of-temperatures is one of:
;  (cons CTemperature '())
;  (cons CTemperature NEList-of-temperatures)
; interpretation non-empty lists of Celsius temperatures

While this definition differs from the preceding list definitions, it shares the critical elements: a self-reference and a clause that does not use a self-reference. Strict adherence to the design recipe demands that you make up some examples of NEList-of-temperatures to ensure that the definition makes sense. As always, you should start with the base clause, meaning the example must look like this:

(cons c '())

where c stands for a CTemperature, like thus: (cons ABSOLUTE0 '()). Also, it is clear that all non-empty elements of List-of-temperatures are also elements of the new class of data: (cons 1 (cons 2 (cons 3 '()))) fits the bill if (cons 2 (cons 3 '())) does, and (cons 2 (cons 3 '())) belongs to NEList-of-temperatures because (cons 3 '()) is an element of NEList-of-temperatures, as confirmed before. Check for yourself that there is no limit on the size of NEList-of-temperatures.

Let’s now return to the problem of designing average so that everyone knows it is for non-empty lists only. With the definition of NEList-of-temperatures, we now have the means to say what we want in the signature:This alternative development explains that, in this case, we can narrow down the domain of average and create a total function.
; NEList-of-temperatures -> Number
; computes the average temperature
(check-expect (average (cons 1 (cons 2 (cons 3 '()))))
(define (average ne-l)
  (/ (sum ne-l)
     (how-many ne-l)))
Naturally the rest remains the same: the purpose statement, the example-test, and the function definition. After all, the very idea of computing the average assumes a non-empty collection of numbers, and that was the entire point of our discussion.

Exercise 144. Will sum and how-many work for NEList-of-temperatures even though they are designed for inputs from List-of-temperatures? If you think they don’t work, provide counter-examples. If you think they would, explain why.

Nevertheless, the definition also raises the question how to design sum and how-many because they consume instances of NEList-of-temperatures now. Here is the obvious result of the first three steps of the design recipe:

; NEList-of-temperatures -> Number
; computes the sum of the given temperatures
  (sum (cons 1 (cons 2 (cons 3 '())))) 6)
(define (sum ne-l) 0)
The example is adapted from the example for average; the dummy definition produces a number, but the wrong one for the given test.

The fourth step is the most interesting part of the design of sum for NEList-of-temperatures. All preceding examples of design demand a template that distinguishes empty lists from non-empty, that is, consed, lists because the data definitions have an appropriate shape. This is not true for NEList-of-temperatures. Here both clauses add consed lists. The two clauses differ, however, in the rest field of these lists. In particular, the first clause always uses '() in the rest field and the second one uses cons instead. Hence the proper condition to distinguish the first kind of data from the second extracts the rest field and then uses empty?:
; NEList-of-temperatures -> Number
(define (sum ne-l)
    [(empty? (rest ne-l)) ...]
    [else ...]))
Here else replaces (cons? (rest ne-l)).

Next you should inspect both clauses and determine whether one or both of them deal with ne-l as if it were a structure. This is of course the case, which the unconditional use of rest on ne-l demonstrates. Put differently, add appropriate selector expressions to the two clauses:
(define (sum ne-l)
    [(empty? (rest ne-l)) (... (first ne-l) ...)]
    [else (... (first ne-l) ... (rest ne-l) ...)]))
Before you read on, explain why the first clause does not contain the selector expression (rest ne-l).

The final question of the template design concerns self-references in the data definition. As you know, NEList-of-temperatures contains one, and therefore the template for sum demands one recursive use:
(define (sum ne-l)
    [(empty? (rest ne-l)) (... (first ne-l) ...)]
     (... (first ne-l) ... (sum (rest ne-l)) ...)]))
Specifically, sum is called on (rest ne-l) in the second clause because the data definition is self-referential at the analogous point.

For the fifth design step, let’s understand how much we already have. Since the first cond clause looks significantly simpler than the second one with its recursive function call, you should start with that one. In this particular case, the condition says that sum is applied to a list with exactly one temperature, (first ne-l). Clearly, this one temperature is the sum of all temperatures on the given list:
(define (sum ne-l)
    [(empty? (rest ne-l)) (first ne-l)]
     (... (first ne-l) ... (sum (rest ne-l)) ...)]))
The second clause says that the list consists of a temperature and at least one more; (first ne-l) extracts the first position and (rest ne-l) the remaining ones. Furthermore, the template suggests to use the result of (sum (rest ne-l)). But sum is the function that you are defining, and you can’t possibly know how it uses (rest ne-l). All you do know is what the purpose statement says, namely, that sum adds all the temperatures on the given list, which is (rest ne-l). If this statement is true, then (sum (rest ne-l)) adds up all but one of the numbers of ne-l. To get the total, the function just has to add the first temperature:
(define (sum ne-l)
    [(empty? (rest ne-l)) (first ne-l)]
    [else (+ (first ne-l) (sum (rest ne-l)))]))
If you now run the test for this function, you will see that the leap of faith is justified. Indeed, for reasons beyond the scope of this book, this leap is always justified, which is why it is an inherent part of the design recipe.

Exercise 145. Design the sorted>? predicate, which consumes a NEList-of-temperatures and produces #true if the temperatures are sorted in descending order. That is, if the second is smaller than the first, the third smaller than the second, and so on. Otherwise it produces #false.

Hint This problem is another one where the table-based method for guessing the combinator works well. Here is a partial table for a number of examples in figure 58. Fill in the rest of the table. Then try to create an expression that computes the result from the pieces.



(first l)


(rest l)


  (rest l))


(cons 1
  (cons 2








(cons 3
  (cons 2




(cons 2 '())




(cons 0
  (cons 3
    (cons 2




(cons 3
 (cons 2





Figure 58: A table for sorted>?

Exercise 146. Design how-many for NEList-of-temperatures. Doing so completes average, so ensure that average passes all of its tests, too.

Exercise 147. Develop a data definition for NEList-of-Booleans, a representation of non-empty lists of Boolean values. Then redesign the functions all-true and one-true from exercise 140.

Exercise 148. Compare the function definitions from this section (sum, how-many, all-true, one-true) with the corresponding function definitions from the preceding sections. Is it better to work with data definitions that accommodate empty lists as opposed to definitions for non-empty lists? Why? Why not?

9.3 Natural Numbers

The BSL programming language supplies many functions that consume lists and a few that produce them, too. Among those is make-list, which consumes a number n together with some other value v and produces a list that contains v n times. Here are some examples:
> (make-list 2 "hello")

(cons "hello" (cons "hello" '()))

> (make-list 3 #true)

(cons #true (cons #true (cons #true '())))

> (make-list 0 17)


In short, even though this function consumes atomic data, it produces arbitrarily large pieces of data. Your question should be how this is possible.

Our answer is that make-list’s input isn’t just a number, it is a special kind of number. In kindergarten you called these numbers “counting numbers”, that is, these numbers are used to count objects. In computer science, these numbers are dubbed natural numbers. Unlike regular numbers, natural numbers come with a data definition:
; An N is one of:
;  0
;  (add1 N)
; interpretation represents the counting numbers
The first clause says that 0 is a natural number; it is used to say that there is no object to be counted. The second clause tells you that if n is a natural number, then n+1 is one too, because add1 is a function that adds 1 to whatever number it is given. We could write this second clause as (+ n 1), but the use of add1 is supposed to signal that this addition is special.

What is special about this use of add1 is that it acts more like a constructor from some structure-type definition than a regular function. For that reason, BSL also comes with the function sub1, which is the “selector” corresponding to add1. Given any natural number m not equal to 0, you can use sub1 to find out the number that went into the construction of m. Put differently, add1 is like cons and sub1 is like first and rest.

At this point you may wonder what the predicates are that distinguish 0 from those natural numbers that are not 0. There are two, just as for lists: zero?, which determines whether some given number is 0, and positive?, which determines whether some number is larger than 0.

Now you are in a position to design functions on natural numbers, such as make-list, yourself. The data definition is already available, so let’s add the header material:
; N String -> List-of-strings
; creates a list of n copies of s
(check-expect (copier 0 "hello") '())
(check-expect (copier 2 "hello")
              (cons "hello" (cons "hello" '())))
(define (copier n s)

Developing the template is the next step. The questions for the template suggest that copier’s body is a cond expression with two clauses: one for 0 and one for positive numbers. Furthermore, 0 is considered atomic and positive numbers are considered structured values, meaning the template needs a selector expression in the second clause. Last but not least, the data definition for N is self-referential in the second clause. Hence the template needs a recursive application to the corresponding selector expression in the second clause:
(define (copier n s)
    [(zero? n) ...]
    [(positive? n) (... (copier (sub1 n) s) ...)]))

; N String -> List-of-strings
; creates a list of n copies of s
(check-expect (copier 0 "hello") '())
(check-expect (copier 2 "hello")
              (cons "hello" (cons "hello" '())))
(define (copier n s)
    [(zero? n) '()]
    [(positive? n) (cons s (copier (sub1 n) s))]))

Figure 59: Creating a list of copies

Figure 59 contains a complete definition of the copier function, as obtained from its template. Let’s reconstruct this step carefully. As always, we start with the cond clause that has no recursive calls. Here the condition tells us that the (important) input is 0, and that means the function must produce a list with 0 items, that is, none. Of course, working through the second example has already clarified this case. Next we turn to the other cond clause and remind ourselves what its expressions compute:
  1. (sub1 n) extracts the natural number that went into the construction of n, which we know is larger than 0;

  2. (copier (sub1 n) s) produces a list of (sub1 n) strings s according to the purpose statement of copier.

But the function is given n and must therefore produce a list with n strings s. Given a list with one too few strings, it is easy to see that the function must simply cons one s onto the result of (copier (sub1 n) s). And that is precisely what the second clause specifies.

At this point, you should run the tests to ensure that this function works at least for the two worked examples. In addition, you may wish to use the function on some additional inputs.

Exercise 149. Does copier function properly when you apply it to a natural number and a Boolean or an image? Or do you have to design another function? Read Abstraction for an answer.

An alternative definition of copier might use else:
(define (copier.v2 n s)
    [(zero? n) '()]
    [else (cons s (copier.v2 (sub1 n) s))]))
How do copier and copier.v2 behave when you apply them to 0.1 and "x"? Explain. Use DrRacket’s stepper to confirm your explanation.

Exercise 150. Design the function add-to-pi. It consumes a natural number n and adds it to pi without using the primitive + operation. Here is a start:
; N -> Number
; computes (+ n pi) without using +
(check-within (add-to-pi 3) (+ 3 pi) 0.001)
(define (add-to-pi n)
Once you have a complete definition, generalize the function to add, which adds a natural number n to some arbitrary number x without using +. Why does the skeleton use check-within?

Exercise 151. Design the function multiply. It consumes a natural number n and multiplies it with a number x without using *.

Use DrRacket’s stepper to evaluate (multiply 3 x) for any x you like. How does multiply relate to what you know from grade school?

Exercise 152. Design two functions: col and row.

The function col consumes a natural number n and an image img. It produces a column—a vertical arrangement—of n copies of img.

The function row consumes a natural number n and an image img. It produces a row—a horizontal arrangement—of n copies of img.

image     image     image

Figure 60: Random attacks

Exercise 153. The goal of this exercise is to visualize the result of a 1968-style European student riot. Here is the rough idea. A small group of students meets to make paint-filled balloons, enters some lecture hall, and randomly throws the balloons at the attendees. Your program displays how the balloons color the seats in the lecture hall.

Use the two functions from exercise 152 to create a rectangle of COLUMNS by ROWS squares, each of which has size 10 by 10. Place it in an empty-scene of the same size. This image is your lecture hall.

Design add-balloons. The function consumes a list of Posn whose coordinates fit into the dimensions of the lecture hall. It produces an image of the lecture hall with red dots added as specified by the Posns.

Figure 60 shows the output of our solution for 10 COLUMNS columns and 20 ROWS when given some list of Posns. The left-most is the clean lecture hall, the second one is after two balloons have hit, and the last one is a highly unlikely distribution of 10 hits. Where is the 10th?

9.4 Russian Dolls

Wikipedia defines a Russian doll as “a set of dolls of decreasing sizes placed one inside the other” and illustrates it with this picture:

In this picture, the dolls are taken apart so that the viewer can see them all.

The problem may strike you as abstract or even absurd; it isn’t clear why you would want to represent Russian dolls or what you would do with such a representation. Just play along for now.

Now consider the problem of representing such Russian dolls with BSL data. With a little bit of imagination, it is easy to see that an artist can create a nest of Russian dolls that consists of an arbitrary number of dolls. After all, it is always possible to wrap another layer around some given Russian doll. Then again, you also know that deep inside there is a solid doll without anything inside.

For each layer of a Russian doll, we could care about many different things: its size, though it is related to the nesting level; its color; the image that is painted on the surface; and so on. Here we just pick one, namely the color of the doll, which we represent with a string. Given that, we know that each layer of the Russian doll has two properties: its color and the doll that is inside. To represent pieces of information with two properties, we always define a structure type:

(define-struct layer [color doll])

And then we add a data definition:
; An RD (short for Russian doll) is one of:
;  String
;  (make-layer String RD)
Naturally, the first clause of this data definition represents the innermost doll, or, to be precise, its color. The second clause is for adding a layer around some given Russian doll. We represent this with an instance of layer, which obviously contains the color of the doll and one other field: the doll that is nested immediately inside of this doll.

Take a look at this doll:


It consists of three dolls. The red one is the innermost one, the green one sits in the middle, and the yellow is the current outermost wrapper. To represent this doll with an element of RD, you start on either end. We proceed from the inside out. The red doll is easy to represent as an RD. Since nothing is inside and since it is red, the string "red" will do fine. For the second layer, we use

(make-layer "green" "red")

which says that a green (hollow) doll contains a red doll. Finally, to get the outside we just wrap another layer around this last doll:

(make-layer "yellow" (make-layer "green" "red"))

This process should give you a good idea of how to go from any set of colored Russian dolls to a data representation. But keep in mind that a programmer must also be able to do the converse, that is, go from a piece of data to concrete information. In this spirit, draw a schematic Russian doll for the following element of RD:

(make-layer "pink" (make-layer "black" "white"))

You might even try this in BSL.

Now that we have a data definition and understand how to represent actual dolls and how to interpret elements of RD as dolls, we are ready to design functions that consume RDs. Specifically, let’s design the function that counts how many dolls a Russian doll set contains. This sentence is a fine purpose statement and determines the signature, too:
; RD -> Number
; how many dolls are part of an-rd
As for data examples, let’s start with (make-layer "yellow" (make-layer "green" "red")). The image above tells us that 3 is the expected answer because there are three dolls: the red one, the green one, and the yellow one. Just working through this one example also tells us that when the input is a representation of this doll


then the answer is 1.

Step four demands the development of a template. Using the standard questions for this step produces this template:
; RD -> Number
; how many dolls are a part of an-rd
(define (depth an-rd)
    [(string? an-rd) ...]
    [(layer? an-rd)
     (... (layer-color an-rd) ...
      ... (depth (layer-doll an-rd)) ...)]))
The number of cond clauses is determined by the number of clauses in the definition of RD. Each of the clauses specifically spells out what kind of data it is about, and that tells us to use the string? and layer? predicates. While strings aren’t compound data, instances of layer contain two values. If the function needs these values, it uses the selector expressions (layer-color an-rd) and (layer-doll an-rd). Finally, the second clause of the data definition contains a self-reference from the doll field of the layer structure to the definition itself. Hence we need a recursive function call for the second selector expression.

The examples and the template almost dictate the function definition. For the non-recursive cond clause, the answer is obviously 1. For the recursive clause, the template expressions compute the following results:
  • (layer-color an-rd) extracts the string that describes the color of the current layer;

  • (layer-doll an-rd) extracts the doll contained within the current layer; and

  • (depth (layer-doll an-rd)) determines how many dolls are part of (layer-doll an-rd), according to the purpose statement of depth.

This last number is almost the desired answer but not quite because the difference between an-rd and (layer-doll an-rd) is one layer, meaning one extra doll. Put differently, the function must add 1 to the recursive result to obtain the actual answer:
; RD -> Number
; how many dolls are a part of an-rd
(define (depth an-rd)
    [(string? an-rd) 1]
    [else (+ (depth (layer-doll an-rd)) 1)]))
Note how the function definition does not use (layer-color an-rd) in the second clause. Once again, we see that the template is an organization schema for everything we know about the data definition, but we may not need all of these pieces for the actual definition.

Let’s finally translate the examples into tests:
(check-expect (depth "red") 1)
   (make-layer "yellow" (make-layer "green" "red")))
If you run these in DrRacket, you will see that their evaluation touches all pieces of the definition of depth.

Exercise 154. Design the function colors. It consumes a Russian doll and produces a string of all colors, separated by a comma and a space. Thus our example should produce

"yellow, green, red"

Exercise 155. Design the function inner, which consumes an RD and produces the (color of the) innermost doll. Use DrRacket’s stepper to evaluate (inner rd) for your favorite rd.

9.5 Lists and World

With lists and self-referential data definitions in general, you can design and run many more interesting world programs than with finite data. Just imagine you can now create a version of the space invader program from Itemizations and Structures that allows the player to fire as many shots from the tank as desired. Let’s start with a simplistic version of this problem:If you haven’t designed a world program in a while, reread Designing World Programs.

Sample Problem Design a world program that simulates firing shots. Every time the “player” hits the space bar, the program adds a shot to the bottom of the canvas. These shots rise vertically at the rate of one pixel per tick.

Designing a world program starts with a separation of information into constants and elements of the ever-changing state of the world. For the former we introduce physical and graphical constants; for the latter we need to develop a data representation for world states. While the sample problem is relatively vague about the specifics, it clearly assumes a rectangular scenery with shots painted along a vertical line. Obviously the locations of the shots change with every clock tick, but the size of the scenery and x-coordinate of the line of shots remain the same:
(define HEIGHT 80) ; distances in terms of pixels
(define WIDTH 100)
(define XSHOTS (/ WIDTH 2))
; graphical constants
(define BACKGROUND (empty-scene WIDTH HEIGHT))
(define SHOT (triangle 3 "solid" "red"))
Nothing in the problem statement demands these particular choices, but as long as they are easy to change—meaning changing by editing a single definition—we have achieved our goal.

As for those aspects of the “world” that change, the problem statement mentions two. First, hitting the space bar adds a shot. Second, all the shots move straight up by one pixel per clock tick. Given that we cannot predict how many shots the player will “fire,” we use a list to represent them:
; A List-of-shots is one of:
;  '()
;  (cons Shot List-of-shots)
; interpretation the collection of shots fired
The one remaining question is how to represent each individual shot. We already know that all of them have the same x-coordinate and that this coordinate stays the same throughout. Furthermore, all shots look alike. Hence, their y-coordinates are the only property in which they differ from each other. It therefore suffices to represent each shot as a number:
; A Shot is a Number.
; interpretation represents the shot's y-coordinate
We could restrict the representation of shots to the interval of numbers below HEIGHT because we know that all shots are launched from the bottom of the canvas and that they then move up, meaning their y-coordinate continuously decreases.

You can also use a data definition like this to represent this world:
; A ShotWorld is List-of-numbers.
; interpretation each number on such a list
;   represents the y-coordinate of a shot
After all, the above two definitions describe all list of numbers; we already have a definition for lists of numbers, and the name ShotWorld tells everyone what this class of data is about.

Once you have defined constants and developed a data representation for the states of the world, the key task is to pick which event handlers you wish to employ and to adapt their signatures to the given problem. The running example mentions clock ticks and the space bar, all of which translates into a wish list of three functions:
  • the function that turns a world state into an image:
    ; ShotWorld -> Image
    ; adds the image of a shot for each  y on w
    ; at (MID,y) to the background image
    (define (to-image w) BACKGROUND)
    because the problem demands a visual rendering;

  • one for dealing with tick events:
    ; ShotWorld -> ShotWorld
    ; moves each shot on w up by one pixel
    (define (tock w) w)

  • and one function for dealing with key events:
    ; ShotWorld KeyEvent -> ShotWorld
    ; adds a shot to the world
    ; if the player presses the space bar
    (define (keyh w ke) w)

Don’t forget that in addition to the initial wish list, you also need to define a main function that actually sets up the world and installs the handlers. Figure 61 includes this one function that is not designed but defined as a modification of standard schema.

Let’s start with the design of to-image. We have its signature, purpose statement, and header, so we need examples next. Since the data definition has two clauses, there should be at least two examples: '() and a consed list, say, (cons 9 '()). The expected result for '() is obviously BACKGROUND; if there is a y-coordinate, though, the function must place the image of a shot at MID and the specified coordinate:
(check-expect (to-image (cons 9 '()))
              (place-image SHOT XSHOTS 9 BACKGROUND))
Before you read on, work through an example that applies to-image to a list of two Shots. Doing so helps understand how the function works.

The fourth step is about translating the data definition into a template:
; ShotWorld -> Image
(define (to-image w)
    [(empty? w) ...]
     (... (first w) ... (to-image (rest w)) ...)]))
The template for data definitions for lists is so familiar now that it doesn’t need much explanation. If you have any doubts, read over the questions in figure 52 and design the template on your own.

From here it is straightforward to define the function. The key is to combine the examples with the template and to answer the questions from figure 53. Following those, you start with the base case of an empty list of shots, and, from the examples, you know that the expected answer is BACKGROUND. Next you formulate what the template expressions in the second cond compute:
  • (first w) extracts the first coordinate from the list;

  • (rest w) is the rest of the coordinates; and

  • (to-image (rest w)) adds each shot on (rest w) to the background image, according to the purpose statement of to-image.

In other words, (to-image (rest w)) renders the rest of the list as an image and thus performs almost all the work. What is missing is the first shot, (first w). If you now apply the purpose statement to these two expressions, you get the desired expression for the second cond clause:
(place-image SHOT XSHOTS (first w)
             (to-image (rest w)))
The added icon is the standard image for a shot; the two coordinates are spelled out in the purpose statement; and the last argument to place-image is the image constructed from the rest of the list.

Figure 61 displays the complete function definition for to-image and indeed the rest of the program, too. The design of tock is just like the design of to-image, and you should work through it for yourself. The signature of the keyh handler, though, poses one interesting question. It specifies that the handler consumes two inputs with nontrivial data definitions. On the one hand, the ShotWorld is a self-referential data definition. On the other hand, the definition for KeyEvents is a large enumeration. For now, we have you “guess” which of the two arguments should drive the development of the template; later we will study such cases in depth.

; ShotWorld -> ShotWorld
(define (main w0)
  (big-bang w0
    [on-tick tock]
    [on-key keyh]
    [to-draw to-image]))
; ShotWorld -> ShotWorld
; moves each shot up by one pixel
(define (tock w)
    [(empty? w) '()]
    [else (cons (sub1 (first w)) (tock (rest w)))]))
; ShotWorld KeyEvent -> ShotWorld
; adds a shot to the world if the space bar is hit
(define (keyh w ke)
  (if (key=? ke " ") (cons HEIGHT w) w))
; ShotWorld -> Image
; adds each shot y on w at (XSHOTS,y} to BACKGROUND
(define (to-image w)
    [(empty? w) BACKGROUND]
    [else (place-image SHOT XSHOTS (first w)
                       (to-image (rest w)))]))

Figure 61: A list-based world program

As far as a world program is concerned, a key handler such as keyh is about the key event that it consumes. Hence, we consider it the main argument and use its data definition to derive the template. Specifically, following the data definition for KeyEvent from Enumerations, it dictates that the function needs a cond expression with numerous clauses like this:
(define (keyh w ke)
    [(key=? ke "left") ...]
    [(key=? ke "right") ...]
    [(key=? ke " ") ...]
    [(key=? ke "a") ...]
    [(key=? ke "z") ...]))
Of course, just like for functions that consume all possible BSL values, a key handler usually does not need to inspect all possible cases. For our running problem, you specifically know that the key handler reacts only to the space bar and all others are ignored. So it is natural to collapse all of the cond clauses into an else clause except for the clause for " ".

Exercise 156. Equip the program in figure 61 with tests and make sure it passes those. Explain what main does. Then run the program via main.

Exercise 157. Experiment to determine whether the arbitrary decisions concerning constants are easy to change. For example, determine whether changing a single constant definition achieves the desired outcome:
  • change the height of the canvas to 220 pixels;

  • change the width of the canvas to 30 pixels;

  • change the x location of the line of shots to “somewhere to the left of the middle”;

  • change the background to a green rectangle; and

  • change the rendering of shots to a red elongated rectangle.

Also check whether it is possible to double the size of the shot without changing anything else or to change its color to black.

Exercise 158. If you run main, press the space bar (fire a shot), and wait for a goodly amount of time, the shot disappears from the canvas. When you shut down the world canvas, however, the result is a world that still contains this invisible shot.

Design an alternative tock function that doesn’t just move shots one pixel per clock tick but also eliminates those whose coordinates place them above the canvas. Hint You may wish to consider the design of an auxiliary function for the recursive cond clause.

Exercise 159. Turn the solution of exercise 153 into a world program. Its main function, dubbed riot, consumes how many balloons the students want to throw; its visualization shows one balloon dropping after another at a rate of one per second. The function produces the list of Posns where the balloons hit.

Hints (1) Here is one possible data representation:
(define-struct pair [balloon# lob])
; A Pair is a structure (make-pair N List-of-posns)
; A List-of-posns is one of:
;  '()
;  (cons Posn List-of-posns)
; interpretation (make-pair n lob) means n balloons
; must yet be thrown and added to lob

(2) A big-bang expression is really just an expression. It is legitimate to nest it within another expression.

(3) Recall that random creates random numbers.

9.6 A Note on Lists and Sets

This book relies on your intuitive understanding of sets as collections of BSL values. The Universe of Data specifically says that a data definition introduces a name for a set of BSL values. There is one question that this book consistently asks about sets, and it is whether some element is in some given set. For example, 4 is in Number, while "four" is not. The book also shows how to use a data definition to check whether some value is a member of some named set and how to use some of the data definitions to generate sample elements of sets, but these two procedures are about data definitions, not sets per se.

At the same time, lists represent collections of values. Hence you might be wondering what the difference between a list and a set is or whether this is a needless distinction. If so, this section is for you.

Right now the primary difference between sets and lists is that the former is a concept we use to discuss steps in the design of code and the latter is one of many forms of data in BSL, our chosen programming language. The two ideas live at rather different levels in our conversations. However, given that a data definition introduces a data representation of actual information inside of BSL and given that sets are collections of information, you may now ask yourself how sets are represented inside of BSL as data.

Most full-fledged languages directly support data representations of both lists and sets.

While lists have a special status in BSL, sets don’t, but at the same time sets somewhat resemble lists. The key difference is the kind of functions a program normally uses with either form of data. BSL provides several basic constants and functions for lists—say, empty, empty?, cons, cons?, first, restand some functions that you could define yourself—for example, member?, length, remove, reverse, and so on. Here is an example of a function you can define but does not come with BSL
; List-of-string String -> N
; determines how often s occurs in los
(define (count los s)
Stop! Finish the design of this function.

Let’s proceed in a straightforward and possibly naive manner and say sets are basically lists. And, to simplify further, let’s focus on lists of numbers in this section. If we now accept that it merely matters whether a number is a part of a set or not, it is almost immediately clear that we can use lists in two different ways to represent sets.

; A Son.L is one of:
;  empty
;  (cons Number Son.L)
; Son is used when it
; applies to Son.L and Son.R


; A Son.R is one of:
;  empty
;  (cons Number Son.R)
; Constraint If s is a Son.R,
; no number occurs twice in s

Figure 62: Two data representations for sets

Figure 62 displays the two data definitions. Both basically say that a set is represented as a list of numbers. The difference is that the definition on the right comes with the constraint that no number may occur more than once on the list. After all, the key question we ask about a set is whether some number is in the set or not, and whether it is in a set once, twice, or three times makes no difference.

Regardless of which definition you choose, you can already define two important notions:
; Son
(define es '())
; Number Son -> Boolean
; is x in s
(define (in? x s)
  (member? x s))
The first one is the empty set, which in both cases is represented by the empty list. The second one is a membership test.

One way to build larger sets is to use cons and the above definitions. Say we wish to build a representation of the set that contains 1, 2, and 3. Here is one such representation:

(cons 1 (cons 2 (cons 3 '())))

And it works for both data representations. But, is

(cons 2 (cons 1 (cons 3 '())))

really not a representation of the same set? Or how about

(cons 1 (cons 2 (cons 1 (cons 3 '()))))

The answer has to be affirmative as long as the primary concern is whether a number is in a set or not. Still, while the order of cons cannot matter, the constraint in the right-hand data definition rules out the last list as a Son.R because it contains 1 twice.

; Number Son.L -> Son.L
; removes x from s
(define s1.L
  (cons 1 (cons 1 '())))
  (set-.L 1 s1.L) es)
(define (set-.L x s)
  (remove-all x s))


; Number Son.R -> Son.R
; removes x from s
(define s1.R
  (cons 1 '()))
  (set-.R 1 s1.R) es)
(define (set-.R x s)
  (remove x s))

Figure 63: Functions for the two data representations of sets

The difference between the two data definitions shows up when we design functions. Say we want a function that removes a number from a set. Here is a wish-list entry that applies to both representations:
; Number Son -> Son
; subtracts x from s
(define (set- x s)
The purpose statement uses the word “subtract” because this is what logicians and mathematicians use when they work with sets.

Figure 63 shows the results. The two columns differ in two points:
  1. The test on the left uses a list that contains 1 twice, while the one on the right represents the same set with a single cons.

  2. Because of these differences, the set- on the left must use remove-all, while the one on the right gets away with remove.

Stop! Copy the code into the DrRacket definitions area and make sure the tests pass. Then read on and experiment with the code as you do.

An unappealing aspect of figure 63 is that the tests use es, a plain list, as the expected result. This problem may seem minor at first glance. Consider the following example, however:

(set- 1 set123)

where set123 represents the set containing 1, 2, and 3 in one of two ways:
(define set123-version1
  (cons 1 (cons 2 (cons 3 '()))))
(define set123-version2
  (cons 1 (cons 3 (cons 2 '()))))
Regardless of which representation we choose, (set- 1 set123) evaluates to one of these two lists:
(define set23-version1
  (cons 2 (cons 3 '())))
(define set23-version2
  (cons 3 (cons 2 '())))
But we cannot predict which of those two set- produces.

For the simple case of two alternatives, it is possible to use the check-member-of testing facility as follows:
(check-member-of (set-.v1 1 set123.v1)
If the expected set contains three elements, there are six possible variations, not including representations with repetitions, which the left-hand data definition allows.

Fixing this problem calls for the combination of two ideas. First, recall that set- is really about ensuring that the given element does not occur in the result. It is an idea that our way of turning the examples into tests does not bring across. Second, with BSL’s check-satisfied testing facility, it is possible to state precisely this idea.

Intermezzo 1: Beginning Student Language briefly mentions check-satisfied, but, in a nutshell, the facility determines whether an expression satisfies a certain property. A property is a function from values to Boolean. In our specific case, we wish to state that 1 is not a member of some set:
; Son -> Boolean
; #true if 1 is not a member of s;  #false otherwise
(define (not-member-1? s)
  (not (in? 1 s)))
Using not-member-1?, we can formulate the test case as follows:

(check-satisfied (set- 1 set123) not-member-1?)

and this variant clearly states what the function is supposed to accomplish. Better yet, this formulation simply does not depend on how the input or output set is represented.

In sum, lists and sets are related in that both are about collections of values, but they also differ strongly:








one among many








# of occurrences







finite but arbitrary


finite or infinite

The last row in this table presents a new idea, though an obvious one, too. Many of the sets mentioned in this book are infinitely large, for example, Number, String, and also List-of-strings. In contrast, a list is always finite though it may contain an arbitrarily large number of items.

In sum, this section explains the essential differences between sets and lists and how to represent finite sets with finite lists in two different ways. BSL is not expressive enough to represent infinite sets; exercise 299 introduces a completely different representation of sets, a representation that can cope with infinite sets, too. The question of how actual programming languages represent sets is beyond the scope of this book, however.

Exercise 160. Design the functions set+.L and set+.R, which create a set by adding a number x to some given set s for the left-hand and right-hand data definition, respectively.

10 More on Lists

Lists are a versatile form of data that come with almost all languages now. Programmers have used them to build large applications, artificial intelligences, distributed systems, and more. This chapter illustrates some ideas from this world, including functions that create lists, data representations that call for structures inside of lists, and representing text files as lists.

10.1 Functions that Produce Lists

Here is a function for determining the wage of an hourly employee:
; Number -> Number
; computes the wage for h hours of work
(define (wage h)
  (* 12 h))
It consumes the number of hours worked and produces the wage. A company that wishes to use payroll software isn’t interested in this function, however. It wants one that computes the wages for all its employees.

Call this new function wage*. Its task is to process all employee work hours and to determine the wages due to each of them. For simplicity, let’s assume that the input is a list of numbers, each representing the number of hours that one employee worked, and that the expected result is a list of the weekly wages earned, also represented with a list of numbers.

Since we already have a data definition for the inputs and outputs, we can immediately move to the second design step:
; List-of-numbers -> List-of-numbers
; computes the weekly wages for the weekly hours
(define (wage* whrs)

Next you need some examples of inputs and the corresponding outputs. So you make up some short lists of numbers that represent weekly hours:







(cons 28 '())


(cons 336 '())

(cons 4 (cons 2 '()))


(cons 48 (cons 24 '()))

In order to compute the output, you determine the weekly wage for each number on the given input list. For the first example, there are no numbers on the input list so the output is '(). Make sure you understand why the second and third expected outputs are what you want.

Given that wage* consumes the same kind of data as several other functions from Lists and given that a template depends only on the shape of the data definition, you can reuse this template:

(define (wage* whrs)
    [(empty? whrs) ...]
    [else (... (first whrs) ...
           ... (wage* (rest whrs)) ...)]))
In case you want to practice the development of templates, use the questions from figure 52.

It is now time for the most creative design step. Following the design recipe, we consider each cond line of the template in isolation. For the non-recursive case, (empty? whrs) is true, meaning the input is '(). The examples from above specify the desired answer, '(), and so we are done.

In the second case, the design questions tell us to state what each expression of the template computes:
  • (first whrs) yields the first number on whrs, which is the first number of hours worked;

  • (rest whrs) is the rest of the given list; and

  • (wage* (rest whrs)) says that the rest is processed by the very function we are defining. As always, we use its signature and its purpose statement to figure out the result of this expression. The signature tells us that it is a list of numbers, and the purpose statement explains that this list represents the list of wages for its input, which is the rest of the list of hours.

The key is to rely on these facts when you formulate the expression that computes the result in this case, even if the function is not yet defined.

Since we already have the list of wages for all but the first item of whrs, the function must perform two computations to produce the expected output for the entire whrs: compute the weekly wage for (first whrs) and construct the list that represents all weekly wages for whrs. For the first part, we reuse wage. For the second, we cons the two pieces of information together into one list:

(cons (wage (first whrs)) (wage* (rest whrs)))

And with that, the definition is complete: see figure 64.

; List-of-numbers -> List-of-numbers
; computes the weekly wages for all given weekly hours
(define (wage* whrs)
    [(empty? whrs) '()]
    [else (cons (wage (first whrs)) (wage* (rest whrs)))]))
; Number -> Number
; computes the wage for h hours of work
(define (wage h)
  (* 12 h))

Figure 64: Computing the wages of all employees

Exercise 161. Translate the examples into tests and make sure they all succeed. Then change the function in figure 64 so that everyone gets $14 per hour. Now revise the entire program so that changing the wage for everyone is a single change to the entire program and not several.

Exercise 162. No employee could possibly work more than 100 hours per week. To protect the company against fraud, the function should check that no item of the input list of wage* exceeds 100. If one of them does, the function should immediately signal an error. How do we have to change the function in figure 64 if we want to perform this basic reality check?

Show the products of the various steps in the design recipe. If you are stuck, show someone how far you got according to the design recipe. The recipe isn’t just a design tool for you to use; it is also a diagnosis system so that others can help you help yourself.

Exercise 163. Design convertFC. The function converts a list of measurements in Fahrenheit to a list of Celsius measurements.

Exercise 164. Design the function convert-euro, which converts a list of US$ amounts into a list of € amounts. Look up the current exchange rate on the web.

Generalize convert-euro to the function convert-euro*, which consumes an exchange rate and a list of US$ amounts and converts the latter into a list of € amounts.

Exercise 165. Design the function subst-robot, which consumes a list of toy descriptions (one-word strings) and replaces all occurrences of "robot" with "r2d2"; all other descriptions remain the same.

Generalize subst-robot to substitute. The latter consumes two strings, called new and old, and a list of strings. It produces a new list of strings by substituting all occurrences of old with new.

10.2 Structures in Lists

Representing a work week as a number is a bad choice because the printing of a paycheck requires more information than hours worked per week. Also, not all employees earn the same amount per hour. Fortunately a list may contain items other than atomic values; indeed, lists may contain whatever values we want, especially structures.

Our running example calls for just such a data representation. Instead of numbers, we use structures that represent employees plus their work hours and pay rates:
(define-struct work [employee rate hours])
; A (piece of) Work is a structure:
;   (make-work String Number Number)
; interpretation (make-work n r h) combines the name
; with the pay rate r and the number of hours h
While this representation is still simplistic, it is just enough of an additional challenge because it forces us to formulate a data definition for lists that contain structures:
; Low (short for list of works) is one of:
;  '()
;  (cons Work Low)
; interpretation an instance of Low represents the
; hours worked for a number of employees

Here are three elements of Low:
(cons (make-work "Robby" 11.95 39)
(cons (make-work "Matthew" 12.95 45)
      (cons (make-work "Robby" 11.95 39)
Use the data definition to explain why these pieces of data belong to Low.

Stop! Also use the data definition to generate two more examples.

When you work on real-world projects, you won’t use such suffixes; instead you will use a tool for managing different versions of code.

Now that you know that the definition of Low makes sense, it is time to redesign the function wage* so that it consumes elements of Low, not just lists of numbers:
; Low -> List-of-numbers
; computes the weekly wages for the given records
(define (wage*.v2 an-low)
The suffix “.v2” at the end of the function name informs every reader of the code that this is a second, revised version of the function. In this case, the revision starts with a new signature and an adapted purpose statement. The header is the same as above.

The third step of the design recipe is to work through an example. Let’s start with the second list above. It contains one work record, namely, (make-work "Robby" 11.95 39). Its interpretation is that "Robby" worked for 39 hours and that he is paid at the rate of $11.95 per hour. Hence his wage for the week is $466.05, that is, (* 11.95 39). The desired result for wage*.v2 is therefore (cons 466.05 '()). Naturally, if the input list contained two work records, we would perform this kind of computation twice, and the result would be a list of two numbers. Stop! Determine the expected result for the third data example above.

Note on Numbers Keep in mind that BSL—unlike most other programming languages—understands decimal numbers just like you do, namely, as exact fractions. A language such as Java, for example, would produce 466.04999999999995 for the expected wage of the first work record. Since you cannot predict when operations on decimal numbers behave in this strange way, you are better off writing down such examples as
    (cons (make-work "Robby" 11.95 39) '()))
  (cons (* 11.95 39) '()))
just to prepare yourself for other programming languages. Then again, writing down the example in this style also means you have really figured out how to compute the wage. End

From here we move on to the development of the template. If you use the template questions, you quickly get this much:
(define (wage*.v2 an-low)
    [(empty? an-low) ...]
    [(cons? an-low)
     (... (first an-low) ...
      ... (wage*.v2 (rest an-low)) ...)]))
because the data definition consists of two clauses, because it introduces '() in the first clause and consed structures in the second, and so on. But you also realize that you know even more about the input than this template expresses. For example, you know that (first an-low) extracts a structure of three fields from the given list. This seems to suggest the addition of three more expressions to the template:
(define (wage*.v2 an-low)
    [(empty? an-low) ...]
    [(cons? an-low)
     (... (first an-low) ...
      ... ... (work-employee (first an-low)) ...
      ... ... (work-rate (first an-low)) ...
      ... ... (work-hours (first an-low)) ...
      (wage*.v2 (rest an-low)) ...)]))
This template lists all potentially interesting data.

We use a different strategy here. Specifically, we suggest that you create and refer to a separate function template whenever you are developing a template for a data definition that refers to other data definitions:
(define (wage*.v2 an-low)
    [(empty? an-low) ...]
    [(cons? an-low)
     (... (for-work (first an-low))
      ... (wage*.v2 (rest an-low)) ...)]))
; Work -> ???
; a template for processing elements of Work
(define (for-work w)
  (... (work-employee w) ...
   ... (work-rate w) ...
   ... (work-hours w) ...))
Splitting the templates leads to a natural partition of work into functions and among functions; none of them grows too large, and all of them relate to a specific data definition.

Finally, you are ready to program. As always you start with the simple-looking case, which is the first cond line here. If wage*.v2 is applied to '(), you expect '() back and that settles it. Next you move on to the second line and remind yourself of what these expressions compute:
  1. (first an-low) extracts the first work structure from the list;

  2. (for-work ...) says that you wish to design a function that processes work structures;

  3. (rest an-low) extracts the rest of the given list; and

  4. (wage*.v2 (rest an-low)) determines the list of wages for all the work records other than the first one, according to the purpose statement of the function.

If you are stuck here, use the table method from figure 54.

If you understand it all, you see that it is enough to cons the two expressions together:
... (cons (for-work (first an-low))
          (wage*.v2 (rest an-low))) ...
assuming that for-work computes the wage for the first work record. In short, you have finished the function by adding another entry to your wish list of functions.

Since for-work is a name that just serves as a stand-in and since it is a bad name for this function, let’s call the function wage.v2 and write down its complete wish-list entry:
; Work -> Number
; computes the wage for the given work record w
(define (wage.v2 w)
The design of this kind of function is extensively covered in Fixed-Size Data and thus doesn’t need any additional explanation here. Figure 65 shows the final result of developing wage.v2 and wage*.v2.

; Low -> List-of-numbers
; computes the weekly wages for all weekly work records
  (wage*.v2 (cons (make-work "Robby" 11.95 39) '()))
  (cons (* 11.95 39) '()))
(define (wage*.v2 an-low)
    [(empty? an-low) '()]
    [(cons? an-low) (cons (wage.v2 (first an-low))
                          (wage*.v2 (rest an-low)))]))
; Work -> Number
; computes the wage for the given work record w
(define (wage.v2 w)
  (* (work-rate w) (work-hours w)))

Figure 65: Computing the wages from work records

Exercise 166. The wage*.v2 function consumes a list of work records and produces a list of numbers. Of course, functions may also produce lists of structures.

Develop a data representation for paychecks. Assume that a paycheck contains two distinctive pieces of information: the employee’s name and an amount. Then design the function wage*.v3. It consumes a list of work records and computes a list of paychecks from it, one per record.

In reality, a paycheck also contains an employee number. Develop a data representation for employee information and change the data definition for work records so that it uses employee information and not just a string for the employee’s name. Also change your data representation of paychecks so that it contains an employee’s name and number, too. Finally, design wage*.v4, a function that maps lists of revised work records to lists of revised paychecks.

Note on Iterative Refinement This exercise demonstrates the iterative refinement of a task. Instead of using data representations that include all relevant information, we started from simplistic representation of paychecks and gradually made the representation realistic. For this simple program, refinement is overkill; later we will encounter situations where iterative refinement is not just an option but a necessity.

Exercise 167. Design the function sum, which consumes a list of Posns and produces the sum of all of its x-coordinates.

Exercise 168. Design the function translate. It consumes and produces lists of Posns. For each (make-posn x y) in the former, the latter contains (make-posn x (+ y 1)). We borrow the word “translate” from geometry, where the movement of a point by a constant distance along a straight line is called a translation.

Exercise 169. Design the function legal. Like translate from exercise 168, the function consumes and produces a list of Posns. The result contains all those Posns whose x-coordinates are between 0 and 100 and whose y-coordinates are between 0 and 200.

Exercise 170. Here is one way to represent a phone number:
(define-struct phone [area switch four])
; A Phone is a structure:
;   (make-phone Three Three Four)
; A Three is a Number between 100 and 999.
; A Four is a Number between 1000 and 9999.
Design the function replace. It consumes and produces a list of Phones. It replaces all occurrence of area code 713 with 281.

10.3 Lists in Lists, Files

Functions and Programs introduces read-file, a function for readingAdd (require 2htdp/batch-io) to your definitions area. an entire text file as a string. In other words, the creator of read-file chose to represent text files as strings, and the function creates the data representation for specific files (specified by a name). Text files aren’t plain long texts or strings, however. They are organized into lines and words, rows and cells, and many other ways. In short, representing the content of a file as a plain string might work on rare occasions but is usually a bad choice.





  Put up in a place

  where it's easy to see

  the cryptic admonishment



  When you feel how depressingly

  slowly you climb,

  it's well to remember that

  Things Take Time.


  Piet Hein


Figure 66: Things take time

For concreteness, take a look at the sample file in figure 66. It contains a poem by Piet Hein, and it consists of many lines and words. When you use the program

(read-file "ttt.txt")

to turn this file into a BSL string, you get this:The dots aren’t really a part of the result, as you probably guessed.

"TTT\n \nPut up in a place\nwhere ...."

where the "\n" inside the string indicates line breaks.

While it is indeed possible to break apart this string with primitive operations on strings, for example, explode, most programming languages—including BSL—support many different representations of files and functions that create such representations from existing files:
  • One way to represent this file is as a list of lines, where each line is represented as one string:
    (cons "TTT"
      (cons ""
        (cons "Put up in a place"
          (cons ...
    Here the second item of the list is the empty string because the file contains an empty line.

  • Another way is to use a list of words, again each word represented as a string:
    (cons "TTT"
      (cons "Put"
        (cons "up"
          (cons "in"
            (cons ...
    Note how the empty second line disappears with this representation. After all, there are no words on the empty line.

  • And a third representation relies on lists of lists of words:
    (cons (cons "TTT" '())
      (cons '()
        (cons (cons "Put"
                (cons "up"
                  (cons ... '())))
          (cons ...
    This representation has an advantage over the second one in that it preserves the organization of the file, including the emptiness of the second line. The price is that all of a sudden lists contain lists.

While the idea of list-containing lists may sound frightening at first, you need not worry. The design recipe helps even with such complications.

; String -> String
; produces the content of file f as a string
(define (read-file f) ...)
; String -> List-of-string
; produces the content of file f as a list of strings,
; one per line
(define (read-lines f) ...)
; String -> List-of-string
; produces the content of file f as a list of strings,
; one per word
(define (read-words f) ...)
; String -> List-of-list-of-string
; produces the content of file f as a list of list of
; strings, one list per line and one string per word
(define (read-words/line f) ...)
; The above functions consume the name of a file as a String
; argument. If the specified file does not exist in the
; same folder as the program, they signal an error.

Figure 67: Reading files

Before we get started, take a look at figure 67. It introduces a number of useful file reading functions. They are not comprehensive: there are many other ways of dealing with text from files, and you will need to know a lot more to deal with all possible text files. For our purposes here—teaching and learning the principles of systematic program design—they suffice, and they empower you to design reasonably interesting programs.

Figure 67 uses the names of two data definitions that do not exist yet, including one involving list-containing lists. As always, we start with a data definition, but this time we leave this task to you. Hence, before you read on, solve the following exercises. The solutions are needed to make complete sense out of the figure, and without working through the solutions, you cannot really understand the rest of this section.

Exercise 171. You know what the data definition for List-of-strings looks like. Spell it out. Make sure that you can represent Piet Hein’s poem as an instance of the definition where each line is represented as a string and another instance where each word is a string. Use read-lines and read-words to confirm your representation choices.

Next develop the data definition for List-of-list-of-strings. Again, represent Piet Hein’s poem as an instance of the definition where each line is represented as a list of strings, one per word, and the entire poem is a list of such line representations. You may use read-words/line to confirm your choice.

As you probably know, operating systems come with programs that measure files. One counts the number of lines, another determines how many words appear per line. Let us start with the latter to illustrate how the design recipe helps with the design of complex functions.

The first step is to ensure that we have all the necessary data definitions. If you solved the above exercise, you have a data definition for all possible inputs of the desired function, and the preceding section defines List-of-numbers, which describes all possible outputs. To keep things short, we use LN to refer to the class of lists of lists of strings, and use it to write down the header material for the desired function:
; LN -> List-of-numbers
; determines the number of words on each line
(define (words-on-line lls) '())
We name the functions words-on-line because it is appropriate and captures the purpose statement in one phrase.

What is really needed, though, is a set of data examples:
(define line0 (cons "hello" (cons "world" '())))
(define line1 '())
(define lls0 '())
(define lls1 (cons line0 (cons line1 '())))
The first two definitions introduce two examples of lines: one contains two words, the other contains none. The last two definitions show how to construct instances of LN from these line examples. Determine what the expected result is when the function is given these two examples.

Once you have data examples, it is easy to formulate functional examples; just imagine applying the function to each of the data examples. When you apply words-on-line to lls0, you should get the empty list back because there are no lines. When you apply words-on-line to lls1, you should get a list of two numbers back because there are two lines. The two numbers are 2 and 0, respectively, given that the two lines in lls1 contain two and no words each.

Here is how you translate all this into test cases:
(check-expect (words-on-line lls0) '())
(check-expect (words-on-line lls1)
              (cons 2 (cons 0 '())))
By doing it at the end of the second step, you have a complete program, though running it just fails some of the test cases.

The development of the template is the interesting step for this sample problem. By answering the template questions from figure 52, you get the usual list-processing template immediately:
(define (words-on-line lls)
    [(empty? lls) ...]
     (... (first lls) ; a list of strings
      ... (words-on-line (rest lls)) ...)]))
As in the preceding section, we know that the expression (first lls) extracts a List-of-strings, which has a complex organization, too. The temptation is to insert a nested template to express this knowledge, but as you should recall, the better idea is to develop a second auxiliary template and to change the first line in the second condition so that it refers to this auxiliary template.

Since this auxiliary template is for a function that consumes a list, the template looks nearly identical to the previous one:
(define (line-processor ln)
    [(empty? ln) ...]
     (... (first ln) ; a string
      ... (line-processor (rest ln)) ...)]))
The important differences are that (first ln) extracts a string from the list, and we consider strings as atomic values. With this template in hand, we can change the first line of the second case in words-on-line to

... (line-processor (first ln)) ...

which reminds us for the fifth step that the definition for words-on-line may demand the design of an auxiliary function.

Now it is time to program. As always, we use the questions from figure 53 to guide this step. The first case, concerning empty lists of lines, is the easy case. Our examples tell us that the answer in this case is '(), that is, the empty list of numbers. The second case, concerning cons, contains several expressions, and we start with a reminder of what they compute:
  • (first ln) extracts the first line from the non-empty list of (represented) lines;

  • (line-processor (first ln)) suggests that we may wish to design an auxiliary function to process this line;

  • (rest ln) is the rest of the list of line; and

  • (words-on-line (rest ln)) computes a list of words per line for the rest of the list. How do we know this? We promised just that with the signature and the purpose statement for words-on-line.

Assuming we can design an auxiliary function that consumes a line and counts the words on one line—let’s call it words#it is easy to complete the second condition:
(cons (words# (first ln))
      (words-on-line (rest ln)))
This expression conses the number of words on the first line of ln onto a list of numbers that represents the number of words on the remainder of the lines of ln.

It remains to design the words# function. Its template is dubbed line-processor and its purpose is to count the number of words on a line, which is just a list of strings. So here is the wish-list entry:
; List-of-strings -> Number
; counts the number of words on los
(define (words# los) 0)
At this point, you may recall the example used to illustrate the design recipe for self-referential data in Designing with Self-Referential Data Definitions. The function is called how-many, and it too counts the number of strings on a list of strings. Even though the input for how-many is supposed to represent a list of names, this difference simply doesn’t matter; as long as it correctly counts the number of strings on a list of strings, how-many solves our problem.

Since it is good to reuse existing functions, you may define words# as
(define (words# los)
  (how-many los))
In reality, however, programming languages come with functions that solve such problems already. BSL calls this function length, and it counts the number of values on any list of values, no matter what the values are.

; An LN is one of:
;  '()
;  (cons Los LN)
; interpretation a list of lines, each is a list of Strings
(define line0 (cons "hello" (cons "world" '())))
(define line1 '())
(define ln0 '())
(define ln1 (cons line0 (cons line1 '())))
; LN -> List-of-numbers
; determines the number of words on each line
(check-expect (words-on-line ln0) '())
(check-expect (words-on-line ln1) (cons 2 (cons 0 '())))
(define (words-on-line ln)
    [(empty? ln) '()]
    [else (cons (length (first ln))
                (words-on-line (rest ln)))]))

Figure 68: Counting the words on a line

You may wish to look over the list of functions that come with BSL. Some may look obscure but may become useful in one of the upcoming problems. Using such functions saves your time, not ours.

Figure 68 summarizes the full design for our sample problem. The figure includes two test cases. Also, instead of using the separate function words#, the definition of words-on-line simply calls the length function that comes with BSL. Experiment with the definition in DrRacket and make sure that the two test cases cover the entire function definition.

With one small step, you can now design your first file utility:
; String -> List-of-numbers
; counts the words on each line in the given file
(define (file-statistic file-name)
    (read-words/line file-name)))
It merely composes a library function with words-on-line. The former reads a file as a List-of-list-of-strings and hands this value to the latter.

This idea of composing a built-in function with a newly designed function is common. Naturally, people don’t design functions randomly and expect to find something in the chosen programming language to complement their design. Instead, program designers plan ahead and design the function to the output that available functions deliver. More generally still and as mentioned above, it is common to think about a solution as a composition of two computations and to develop an appropriate data collection with which to communicate the result of one computation to the second one, where each computation is implemented with a function.

; 1String -> String
; converts the given 1String to a 3-letter numeric String
(check-expect (encode-letter "z") (code1 "z"))
(check-expect (encode-letter "\t")
              (string-append "00" (code1 "\t")))
(check-expect (encode-letter "a")
              (string-append "0" (code1 "a")))
(define (encode-letter s)
    [(>= (string->int s) 100) (code1 s)]
    [(< (string->int s) 10)
     (string-append "00" (code1 s))]
    [(< (string->int s) 100)
     (string-append "0" (code1 s))]))
; 1String -> String
; converts the given 1String into a String
(check-expect (code1 "z") "122")
(define (code1 c)
  (number->string (string->int c)))

Figure 69: Encoding strings

Exercise 172. Design the function collapse, which converts a list of lines into a string. The strings should be separated by blank spaces (" "). The lines should be separated with a newline ("\n").

Challenge When you are finished, use the program like this:
(write-file "ttt.dat"
            (collapse (read-words/line "ttt.txt")))
To make sure the two files "ttt.dat" and "ttt.txt" are identical, remove all extraneous white spaces in your version of the T.T.T. poem.

Exercise 173. Design a program that removes all articles from a text file. The program consumes the name n of a file, reads the file, removes the articles, and writes the result out to a file whose name is the result of concatenating "no-articles-" with n. For this exercise, an article is one of the following three words: "a", "an", and "the".

Use read-words/line so that the transformation retains the organization of the original text into lines and words. When the program is designed, run it on the Piet Hein poem.

Exercise 174. Design a program that encodes text files numerically. Each letter in a word should be encoded as a numeric three-letter string with a value between 0 and 256. Figure 69 shows our encoding function for single letters. Before you start, explain these functions.

Hints (1) Use read-words/line to preserve the organization of the file into lines and words. (2) Read up on explode again.

Exercise 175. Design a BSL program that simulates the Unix command wc. The purpose of the command is to count the number of 1Strings, words, and lines in a given file. That is, the command consumes the name of a file and produces a value that consists of three numbers.

; Matrix -> Matrix
; transposes the given matrix along the diagonal
(define wor1 (cons 11 (cons 21 '())))
(define wor2 (cons 12 (cons 22 '())))
(define tam1 (cons wor1 (cons wor2 '())))
(check-expect (transpose mat1) tam1)
(define (transpose lln)
    [(empty? (first lln)) '()]
    [else (cons (first* lln) (transpose (rest* lln)))]))

Figure 70: Transpose a matrix

Exercise 176. Mathematics teachers may have introduced you to matrix calculations by now. In principle, matrix just means rectangle of numbers. Here is one possible data representation for matrices:
; A Matrix is one of:
;  (cons Row '())
;  (cons Row Matrix)
; constraint all rows in matrix are of the same length
; A Row is one of:
;  '()
;  (cons Number Row)
Note the constraints on matrices. Study the data definition and translate the two-by-two matrix consisting of the numbers 11, 12, 21, and 22 into this data representation. Stop, don’t read on until you have figured out the data examples.

Here is the solution for the five-second puzzle:
(define row1 (cons 11 (cons 12 '())))
(define row2 (cons 21 (cons 22 '())))
(define mat1 (cons row1 (cons row2 '())))
If you didn’t create it yourself, study it now.

The function in figure 70 implements the important mathematical operation of transposing the entries in a matrix. To transpose means to mirror the entries along the diagonal, that is, the line from the top-left to the bottom-right.

Stop! Transpose mat1 by hand, then read figure 70. Why does transpose ask (empty? (first lln))?

The definition assumes two auxiliary functions:
  • first*, which consumes a matrix and produces the first column as a list of numbers; and

  • rest*, which consumes a matrix and removes the first column. The result is a matrix.

Even though you lack definitions for these functions, you should be able to understand how transpose works. You should also understand that you cannot design this function with the design recipes you have seen so far. Explain why.

Design the two wish-list functions. Then complete the design of transpose with some test cases.

10.4 A Graphical Editor, Revisited

A Graphical Editor is about the design of an interactive graphical one-line editor. It suggests two different ways to represent the state of the editor and urges you to explore both: a structure that contains a pair of strings or a structure that combines a string with an index to a current position (see exercise 87).

A third alternative is to use structures that combine two lists of 1Strings:
(define-struct editor [pre post])
; An Editor is a structure:
;   (make-editor Lo1S Lo1S)
; An Lo1S is one of:
;  '()
;  (cons 1String Lo1S)
Before you wonder why, let’s make up two data examples:
(define good
  (cons "g" (cons "o" (cons "o" (cons "d" '())))))
(define all
  (cons "a" (cons "l" (cons "l" '()))))
(define lla
  (cons "l" (cons "l" (cons "a" '()))))
; data example 1:
(make-editor all good)
; data example 2:
(make-editor lla good)
The two examples demonstrate how important it is to write down an interpretation. While the two fields of an editor clearly represent the letters to the left and right of the cursor, the two examples demonstrate that there are at least two ways to interpret the structure types:
  1. (make-editor pre post) could mean the letters in pre precede the cursor and those in post succeed it and that the combined text is

    (string-append (implode pre) (implode post))

    Recall that implode turns a list of 1Strings into a String.

  2. (make-editor pre post) could equally well mean that the letters in pre precede the cursor in reverse order. If so, we obtain the text in the displayed editor like this:
    (string-append (implode (rev pre))
                   (implode post))
    The function rev must consume a list of 1Strings and reverse it.

Even without a complete definition for rev, you can imagine how it works. Use this understanding to make sure you understand that translating the first data example into information according to the first interpretation and treating the second data example according to the second interpretation yields the same editor display:


Both interpretations are fine choices, but it turns out that using the second one greatly simplifies the design of the program. The rest of this section demonstrates this point, illustrating the use of lists inside of structures at the same time. To appreciate the lesson properly, you should have solved the exercises in A Graphical Editor.

Let’s start with rev because we clearly need this function to make sense out of the data definition. Its header material is straightforward:
; Lo1s -> Lo1s
; produces a reverse version of the given list
  (rev (cons "a" (cons "b" (cons "c" '()))))
  (cons "c" (cons "b" (cons "a" '()))))
(define (rev l) l)
For good measure, we have added one “obvious” example as a test case. You may want to add some extra examples just to make sure you understand what is needed.

The template for rev is the usual list template:
(define (rev l)
    [(empty? l) ...]
    [else (... (first l) ...
           ... (rev (rest l)) ...)]))
There are two cases, and the second case comes with several selector expressions and a self-referential one.

Filling in the template is easy for the first clause: the reverse version of the empty list is the empty list. For the second clause, we once again use the coding questions:
  • (first l) is the first item on the list of 1Strings;

  • (rest l) is the rest of the list; and

  • (rev (rest l)) is the reverse of the rest of the list.

Stop! Try to finish the design of rev with these hints.







 (rest l))


(rev l)

(cons "a"








(cons "a"

(cons "a"
  (cons "b"
    (cons "c"




(cons "b"
  (cons "c"


(cons "c"
  (cons "b"


(cons "c"
  (cons "b"
    (cons "a"

Figure 71: Tabulating for rev

If these hints leave you stuck, remember to create a table from the examples. Figure 71 shows the table for two examples: (cons "a" '()) and (cons "a" (cons "b" (cons "c" '()))). The second example is particularly illustrative. A look at the next to last column shows that (rev (rest l)) accomplishes most of the work by producing (cons "c" (cons "b" '())). Since the desired result is (cons "c" (cons "b" (cons "a" '()))), rev must somehow add "a" to the end of the result of the recursion. Indeed, because (rev (rest l)) is always the reverse of the rest of the list, it clearly suffices to add (first l) to its end. While we don’t have a function that adds items to the end of a list, we can wish for it and use it to complete the function definition:
(define (rev l)
    [(empty? l) '()]
    [else (add-at-end (rev (rest l)) (first l))]))

Here is the extended wish-list entry for add-at-end:
; Lo1s 1String -> Lo1s
; creates a new list by adding s to the end of l
  (add-at-end (cons "c" (cons "b" '())) "a")
  (cons "c" (cons "b" (cons "a" '()))))
(define (add-at-end l s)
It is “extended” because it comes with an example formulated as a test case. The example is derived from the example for rev, and indeed, it is precisely the example that motivates the wish-list entry. Make up an example where add-at-end consumes an empty list before you read on.

Since add-at-end is also a list-processing function, the template is just a renaming of the one you know so well now:
(define (add-at-end l s)
    [(empty? l) ...]
    [else (... (first l) ...
           ... (add-at-end (rest l) s) ...)]))
To complete it into a function definition, we proceed according to the recipe questions for step 5. Our first question is to formulate an answer for the “basic” case, that is, the first case here. If you worked through the suggested exercise, you know that the result of

(add-at-end '() s)

is always (cons s '()). After all, the result must be a list and the list must contain the given 1String.

The next two questions concern the “complex” or “self-referential” case. We know what the expressions in the second cond line compute: the first expression extracts the first 1String from the given list and the second expression “creates a new list by adding s to the end of (rest l).” That is, the purpose statement dictates what the function must produce here. From here, it is clear that the function must add (first l) back to the result of the recursion:
(define (add-at-end l s)
    [(empty? l) (cons s '())]
     (cons (first l) (add-at-end (rest l) s))]))
Run the tests-as-examples to reassure yourself that this function works and that therefore rev works, too. Of course, you shouldn’t be surprised to find out that BSL already provides a function that reverses any given list, including lists of 1Strings. And naturally, it is called reverse.

Exercise 177. Design the function create-editor. The function consumes two strings and produces an Editor. The first string is the text to the left of the cursor and the second string is the text to the right of the cursor. The rest of the section relies on this function.

At this point, you should have a complete understanding of our data representation for the graphical one-line editor. Following the design strategy for interactive programs from Designing World Programs, you should define physical constants—the width and height of the editor, for example—and graphical constants—for example, the cursor. Here are ours:
(define HEIGHT 20) ; the height of the editor
(define WIDTH 200) ; its width
(define FONT-SIZE 16) ; the font size
(define FONT-COLOR "black") ; the font color
(define MT (empty-scene WIDTH HEIGHT))
(define CURSOR (rectangle 1 HEIGHT "solid" "red"))
The important point, however, is to write down the wish list for your event handler(s) and your function that draws the state of the editor. Recall that the 2htdp/universe library dictates the header material for these functions :
; Editor -> Image
; renders an editor as an image of the two texts
; separated by the cursor
(define (editor-render e) MT)
; Editor KeyEvent -> Editor
; deals with a key event, given some editor
(define (editor-kh ed ke) ed)
In addition, Designing World Programs demands that you write down a main function for your program:
; main : String -> Editor
; launches the editor given some initial string
(define (main s)
   (big-bang (create-editor s "")
     [on-key editor-kh]
     [to-draw editor-render]))
Reread exercise 177 to determine the initial editor for this program.

While it does not matter which wish you tackle next, we choose to design editor-kh first and editor-render second. Since we have the header material, let’s explain the functioning of the key-event handler with two examples:
(check-expect (editor-kh (create-editor "" "") "e")
              (create-editor "e" ""))
  (editor-kh (create-editor "cd" "fgh") "e")
  (create-editor "cde" "fgh"))
Both of these examples demonstrate what happens when you press the letter “e” on your keyboard. The computer runs the function editor-kh on the current state of the editor and "e". In the first example, the editor is empty, which means that the result is an editor with just the letter "e" in it followed by the cursor. In the second example, the cursor is between the strings "cd" and "fgh", and therefore the result is an editor with the cursor between "cde" and "fgh". In short, the function always inserts any normal letter at the cursor position.

Before you read on, you should make up examples that illustrate how editor-kh works when you press the backspace ("\b") key to delete some letter, the "left" and "right" arrow keys to move the cursor, or some other arrow keys. In all cases, consider what should happen when the editor is empty, when the cursor is at the left end or right end of the non-empty string in the editor, and when it is in the middle. Even though you are not working with intervals here, it is still a good idea to develop examples for the “extreme” cases.

Once you have test cases, it is time to develop the template. In the case of editor-kh you are working with a function that consumes two complex forms of data: one is a structure containing lists, the other one is a large enumeration of strings. Generally speaking, this design case calls for an improved design recipe; but in cases like these, it is also clear that you should deal with one of the inputs first, namely, the keystroke.

Having said that, the template is just a large cond expression for checking which KeyEvent the function received:
(define (editor-kh ed k)
    [(key=? k "left") ...]
    [(key=? k "right") ...]
    [(key=? k "\b") ...]
    [(key=? k "\t") ...]
    [(key=? k "\r") ...]
    [(= (string-length k) 1) ...]
    [else ...]))
The cond expression doesn’t quite match the data definition for KeyEvent because some KeyEvents need special attention ("left", "\b", and so on), some need to be ignored because they are special ("\t" and "\r"), and some should be classified into one large group (ordinary keys).

Exercise 178. Explain why the template for editor-kh deals with "\t" and "\r" before it checks for strings of length 1.

For the fifth step—the definition of the function—we tackle each clause in the conditional separately. The first clause demands a result that moves the cursor and leaves the string content of the editor alone. So does the second clause. The third clause, however, demands the deletion of a letter from the editor’s content—if there is a letter. Last, the sixth cond clause concerns the addition of letters at the cursor position. Following the first basic guideline, we make extensive use of a wish-list and imagine one function per task:
(define (editor-kh ed k)
    [(key=? k "left") (editor-lft ed)]
    [(key=? k "right") (editor-rgt ed)]
    [(key=? k "\b") (editor-del ed)]
    [(key=? k "\t") ed]
    [(key=? k "\r") ed]
    [(= (string-length k) 1) (editor-ins ed k)]
    [else ed]))

As you can tell from the definition of editor-kh, three of the four wish-list functions have the same signature:

; Editor -> Editor

The last one takes two arguments instead of one:
We leave the proper formulation of wishes for the first three functions to you and focus on the fourth one.

Let’s start with a purpose statement and a function header:
; insert the 1String k between pre and post
(define (editor-ins ed k)
The purpose is straight out of the problem statement. For the construction of a function header, we need an instance of Editor. Since pre and post are the pieces of the current one, we just put them back together.

Next we derive examples for editor-ins from those for editor-kh:
  (editor-ins (make-editor '() '()) "e")
  (make-editor (cons "e" '()) '()))
    (make-editor (cons "d" '())
                 (cons "f" (cons "g" '())))
  (make-editor (cons "e" (cons "d" '()))
               (cons "f" (cons "g" '()))))
You should work through these examples using the interpretation of Editor. That is, make sure you understand what the given editor means in terms of information and what the function call is supposed to achieve in those terms. In this particular case, it is best to draw the visual representation of the editor because it represents the information well.

The fourth step demands the development of the template. The first argument is guaranteed to be a structure, and the second one is a string, an atomic piece of data. In other words, the template just pulls out the pieces from the given editor representation:
(define (editor-ins ed k)
  (... ed ... k ...
   ... (editor-pre ed) ...
   ... (editor-post ed) ...))
Remember a template lists parameters because they are available, too.

From the template and the examples, it is relatively easy to conclude that editor-ins is supposed to create an editor from the given editor’s pre and post fields with k added to the front of the former:
(define (editor-ins ed k)
  (make-editor (cons k (editor-pre ed))
               (editor-post ed)))
Even though both (editor-pre ed) and (editor-post ed) are lists of 1Strings, there is no need to design auxiliary functions. To get the desired result, it suffices to use cons, which creates lists.

At this point, you should do two things. First, run the tests for this function. Second, use the interpretation of Editor and explain abstractly why this function performs the insertion. And as if this isn’t enough, you may wish to compare this simple definition with the one from exercise 84 and figure out why the other one needs an auxiliary function while our definition here doesn’t.

Exercise 179. Design the functions
; Editor -> Editor
; moves the cursor position one 1String left,
; if possible
(define (editor-lft ed) ed)
; Editor -> Editor
; moves the cursor position one 1String right,
; if possible
(define (editor-rgt ed) ed)
; Editor -> Editor
; deletes a 1String to the left of the cursor,
; if possible
(define (editor-del ed) ed)
Again, it is critical that you work through a good range of examples.

Designing the rendering function for Editors poses some new but small challenges. The first one is to develop a sufficiently large number of test cases. On the one hand, it demands coverage of the possible combinations: an empty string to the left of the cursor, an empty one on the right, and both strings empty. On the other hand, it also requires some experimenting with the functions that the image library provides. Specifically, it needs a way to compose the two pieces of strings rendered as text images, and it needs a way of placing the text image into the empty image frame (MT). Here is what we do to create an image for the result of (create-editor "pre" "post"):
  (beside (text "pre" FONT-SIZE FONT-COLOR)
          (text "post" FONT-SIZE FONT-COLOR))
  1 1
  "left" "top"
If you compare this with the editor image above, you notice some differences, which is fine because the exact layout isn’t essential to the purpose of this exercise, and because the revised layout doesn’t trivialize the problem. In any case, do experiment in the interactions area of DrRacket to find your favorite editor display.

You are now ready to develop the template, and you should come up with this much:
(define (editor-render e)
  (... (editor-pre e) ... (editor-post e)))
The given argument is just a structure type with two fields. Their values, however, are lists of 1Strings, and you might be tempted to refine the template even more. Don’t! Instead, keep in mind that when one data definition refers to another complex data definition, you are better off using the wish list.

If you have worked through a sufficient number of examples, you also know what you want on your wish list: one function that turns a string into a text of the right size and color. Let’s call this function editor-text. Then the definition of editor-render just uses editor-text twice and then composes the result with beside and place-image:
; Editor -> Image
(define (editor-render e)
    (beside (editor-text (editor-pre e))
            (editor-text (editor-post e)))
    1 1
    "left" "top"
Although this definition nests expressions three levels deep, the use of the imaginary editor-text function renders it quite readable.

What remains is to design editor-text. From the design of editor-render, we know that editor-text consumes a list of 1Strings and produces a text image:
; Lo1s -> Image
; renders a list of 1Strings as a text image
(define (editor-text s)
This dummy definition produces an empty text image.

To demonstrate what editor-text is supposed to compute, we work through an example. The example input is

(create-editor "pre" "post")

which was also used to explain editor-render and is equivalent to
  (cons "e" (cons "r" (cons "p" '())))
  (cons "p" (cons "o" (cons "s" (cons "t" '())))))
We pick the second list as our sample input for editor-text, and we know the expected result from the example for editor-render:
   (cons "p" (cons "o" (cons "s" (cons "t" '())))))
  (text "post" FONT-SIZE FONT-COLOR))
You may wish to make up a second example before reading on.

Given that editor-text consumes a list of 1Strings, we can write down the template without much ado:
(define (editor-text s)
    [(empty? s) ...]
    [else (... (first s)
           ... (editor-text (rest s)) ...)]))
After all, the template is dictated by the data definition that describes the function input. But you don’t need the template if you understand and keep in mind the interpretation for Editor. It uses explode to turn a string into a list of 1Strings. Naturally, there is a function implode that performs the inverse computation, that is,
> (implode
   (cons "p" (cons "o" (cons "s" (cons "t" '())))))


Using this function, the definition of editor-text is just a small step from the example to the function body:
(define (editor-text s)
  (text (implode s) FONT-SIZE FONT-COLOR))

Exercise 180. Design editor-text without using implode.

The true surprise comes when you test the two functions. While our test for editor-text succeeds, the test for editor-render fails. An inspection of the failure shows that the string to the left of the cursor— "pre"is typeset backward. We forgot that this part of the editor’s state is represented in reverse. Fortunately, the unit tests for the two functions pinpoint which function is wrong and even tell us what is wrong with the function and suggest how to fix the problem:
(define (editor-render ed)
    (beside (editor-text (reverse (editor-pre ed)))
            (editor-text (editor-post ed)))
    1 1
    "left" "top"
This definition uses the reverse function on the pre field of ed.

Note Modern applications allow users to position the cursor with the mouse (or other gesture-based devices). While it is in principle possible to add this capability to your editor, we wait with doing so until A Graphical Editor, with Mouse.

11 Design by Composition

By now you know that programs are complex products and that their production requires the design of many collaborating functions. This collaboration works well if the designer knows when to design several functions and how to compose these functions into one program.

You have encountered this need to design interrelated functions several times. Sometimes a problem statement implies several different tasks, and each task is best realized with a function. At other times, a data definition may refer to another one, and in that case, a function processing the former kind of data relies on a function processing the latter.

In this chapter, we present several scenarios that call for the design of programs that compose many functions. To support this kind of design, the chapter presents some informal guidelines on divvying up functions and composing them. Since these examples demand complex forms of lists, however, this chapter starts with a section on concise list notation.

11.1 The list Function

At this point, you should have tired of writing so many conses just to create a list, especially for lists that contain a bunch of values. Fortunately, we have an additional teaching language for you thatYou have graduated from BSL. It is time to use the “Language” menu and to select “Beginning Student with List Abbreviations” for your studies. provides mechanisms for simplifying this part of a programmer’s life. BSL+ does so, too.

The key innovation is list, which consumes an arbitrary number of values and creates a list. The simplest way to understand list is to think of it as an abbreviation. Specifically, every expression of the shape

(list exp-1 ... exp-n)

stands for a series of n cons expressions:

(cons exp-1 (cons ... (cons exp-n '())))

Keep in mind that '() is not an item of the list here, but actually the rest of the list. Here is a table with three examples:




(list "ABC")


(cons "ABC" '())

(list #false #true)


(cons #false (cons #true '()))

(list 1 2 3)


(cons 1 (cons 2 (cons 3 '())))

They introduce lists with one, two, and three items, respectively.

Of course, we can apply list not only to values but also to expressions:
> (list (+ 0 1) (+ 1 1))

(list 1 2)

> (list (/ 1 0) (+ 1 1))

/:division by zero

Before the list is constructed, the expressions must be evaluated. If during the evaluation of an expression an error occurs, the list is never formed. In short, list behaves just like any other primitive operation that consumes an arbitrary number of arguments; its result just happens to be a list constructed with conses.

The use of list greatly simplifies the notation for lists with many items and lists that contain lists or structures. Here is an example:

(list 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9)

This list contains 10 items and its formation with cons would require 10 uses of cons and one instance of '(). Similarly, the list
(list (list "bob" 0 "a")
      (list "carl" 1 "a")
      (list "dana" 2 "b")
      (list "erik" 3 "c")
      (list "frank" 4 "a")
      (list "grant" 5 "b")
      (list "hank" 6 "c")
      (list "ian" 7 "a")
      (list "john" 8 "d")
      (list "karel" 9 "e"))
requires 11 uses of list, which sharply contrasts with 40 cons and 11 additional uses of '().

Exercise 181. Use list to construct the equivalent of these lists:
  1. (cons "a" (cons "b" (cons "c" (cons "d" '()))))

  2. (cons (cons 1 (cons 2 '())) '())

  3. (cons "a" (cons (cons 1 '()) (cons #false '())))

  4. (cons (cons "a" (cons 2 '())) (cons "hello" '()))

Also try your hand at this one:
(cons (cons 1 (cons 2 '()))
      (cons (cons 2 '())
Start by determining how many items each list and each nested list contains. Use check-expect to express your answers; this ensures that your abbreviations are really the same as the long-hand.

Exercise 182. Use cons and '() to form the equivalent of these lists:
  1. (list 0 1 2 3 4 5)

  2. (list (list "he" 0) (list "it" 1) (list "lui" 14))

  3. (list 1 (list 1 2) (list 1 2 3))

Use check-expect to express your answers.

Exercise 183. On some occasions lists are formed with cons and list.
  1. (cons "a" (list 0 #false))

  2. (list (cons 1 (cons 13 '())))

  3. (cons (list 1 (list 13 '())) '())

  4. (list '() '() (cons 1 '()))

  5. (cons "a" (cons (list 1) (list #false '())))

Reformulate each of the following expressions using only cons or only list. Use check-expect to check your answers.

Exercise 184. Determine the values of the following expressions:
  1. (list (string=? "a" "b") #false)

  2. (list (+ 10 20) (* 10 20) (/ 10 20))

  3. (list "dana" "jane" "mary" "laura")

Use check-expect to express your answers.

Exercise 185. You know about first and rest from BSL, but BSL+ comes with even more selectors than that. Determine the values of the following expressions:
  1. (first (list 1 2 3))

  2. (rest (list 1 2 3))

  3. (second (list 1 2 3))

Find out from the documentation whether third and fourth exist.

11.2 Composing Functions

How to Design Programs explains that programs are collections of definitions: structure type definitions, data definitions, constant definitions, and function definitions.And don’t forget tests. To guide the division of labor among functions, the section also suggests a rough guideline:

Design one function per task. Formulate auxiliary function definitions for every dependency between quantities in the problem.

This part of the book introduces another guideline on auxiliary functions:

Design one template per data definition. Formulate auxiliary function definitions when one data definition points to a second data definition.

In this section, we take a look at one specific place in the design process that may call for additional auxiliary functions: the definition step, which creates a full-fledged definition from a template. Turning a template into a complete function definition means combining the values of the template’s sub-expressions into the final answer. As you do so, you might encounter several situations that suggest the need for auxiliary functions:
  1. If the composition of values requires knowledge of a particular domain of application—for example, composing two (computer) images, accounting, music, or science—design an auxiliary function.

  2. If the composition of values requires a case analysis of the available values—for example, depends on a number being positive, zero, or negative— use a cond expression. If the cond looks complex, design an auxiliary function whose arguments are the template’s expressions and whose body is the cond expression.

  3. If the composition of values must process an element from a self-referential data definition—a list, a natural number, or something like those—design an auxiliary function.

  4. If everything fails, you may need to design a more general function and define the main function as a specific use of the general function. This suggestion sounds counterintuitive, but it is called for in a remarkably large number of cases.

The last two criteria are situations that we haven’t discussed in any detail, though examples have come up before. The next two sections illustrate these principles with additional examples.

Before we continue, though, remember that the key to managing the design of programs is to maintain the often-mentioned

Wish List

Maintain a list of function headers that must be designed to complete a program. Writing down complete function headers ensures that you can test those portions of the programs that you have finished, which is useful even though many tests will fail. Of course, when the wish list is empty, all tests should pass and all functions should be covered by tests.

Before you put a function on the wish list, you should check whether something like the function already exists in your language’s library or whether something similar is already on the wish list. BSL, BSL+, and indeed all programming languages provide many built-in operations and many library functions. You should explore your chosen language when you have time and when you have a need, so that you know what it provides.

11.3 Auxiliary Functions that Recur

People need to sort things all the time, and so do programs. Investment advisors sort portfolios by the profit each holding generates. Game programs sort lists of players according to scores. And mail programs sort messages according to date or sender or some other criterion.

In general, you can sort a bunch of items if you can compare and order each pair of data items. Although not every kind of data comes with a comparison primitive, we all know one that does: numbers. Hence, we use a simplistic but highly representative sample problem in this section:

Sample Problem Design a function that sorts a list of reals.

The exercises below clarify how to adapt this function to other data.

Since the problem statement does not mention any other task and since sorting does not seem to suggest other tasks, we just follow the design recipe. Sorting means rearranging a bunch of numbers. This restatement implies a natural data definition for the inputs and outputs of the function and thus its signature. Given that we have a definition for List-of-numbers, the first step is easy:
; List-of-numbers -> List-of-numbers
; produces a sorted version of alon
(define (sort> alon)
Returning alon ensures that the result is appropriate as far as the function signature is concerned, but in general, the given list isn’t sorted and this result is wrong.

When it comes to making up examples, it quickly becomes clear that the problem statement is quite imprecise. As before, we use the data definition of List-of-numbers to organize the development of examples. Since the data definition consists of two clauses, we need two examples. Clearly, when sort> is applied to '(), the result must be '(). The question is what the result for

(cons 12 (cons 20 (cons -5 '())))

should be. The list isn’t sorted, but there are two ways to sort it:
  • (cons 20 (cons 12 (cons -5 '()))), that is, a list with the numbers arranged in descending order; and

  • (cons -5 (cons 12 (cons 20 '()))), that is, a list with the numbers arranged in ascending order.

In a real-world situation, you would now have to ask the person who posed the problem for clarification. Here we go for the descending alternative; designing the ascending alternative doesn’t pose any different obstacles.

The decision calls for a revision of the header material:
; List-of-numbers -> List-of-numbers
; rearranges alon in descending order
(check-expect (sort> '()) '())
(check-expect (sort> (list 3 2 1)) (list 3 2 1))
(check-expect (sort> (list 1 2 3)) (list 3 2 1))
(check-expect (sort> (list 12 20 -5))
              (list 20 12 -5))
(define (sort> alon)
The header material now includes the examples reformulated as unit tests and using list. If the latter makes you uncomfortable, reformulate the test with cons to exercise translating back and forth. As for the additional two examples, they demand that sort> works on lists already sorted in ascending and descending order.

Next we must translate the data definition into a function template. We have dealt with lists of numbers before, so this step is easy:
(define (sort> alon)
    [(empty? alon) ...]
    [else (... (first alon) ...
           ... (sort> (rest alon)) ...)]))

Using this template, we can finally turn to the interesting part of the program development. We consider each case of the cond expression separately, starting with the simple case. If sort>’s input is '(), the answer is '(), as specified by the example. If sort>’s input is a consed list, the template suggests two expressions that might help:
  • (first alon) extracts the first number from the input; and

  • (sort> (rest alon)) rearranges (rest alon) in descending order, according to the purpose statement of the function.

To clarify these abstract answers, let’s use the second example to explain these pieces in detail. When sort> consumes (list 12 20 -5),
  1. (first alon) is 12,

  2. (rest alon) is (list 20 -5), and

  3. (sort> (rest alon)) produces (list 20 -5) because this list is already sorted.

To produce the desired answer, sort> must insert 12 between the two numbers of the last list. More generally, we must find an expression that inserts (first alon) in its proper place into the result of (sort> (rest alon)). If we can do so, sorting is an easily solved problem.

Inserting a number into a sorted list clearly isn’t a simple task. It demands searching through the sorted list to find the proper place of the item. Searching through any list demands an auxiliary function because lists are of arbitrary size and, by item 3 of the preceding section, processing values of arbitrary size calls for the design of an auxiliary function.

So here is the new wish-list entry:
; Number List-of-numbers -> List-of-numbers
; inserts n into the sorted list of numbers alon
(define (insert n alon) alon)
That is, insert consumes a number and a list sorted in descending order and produces a sorted list by inserting the former into the latter.

With insert, it is easy to complete the definition of sort>:
(define (sort> alon)
    [(empty? alon) '()]
     (insert (first alon) (sort> (rest alon)))]))
In order to produce the final result, sort> extracts the first item of a non-empty list, computes the sorted version of the rest, and uses insert to produce the completely sorted list from the two pieces.

Stop! Test the program as is. Some test cases pass, and some fail. That’s progress. The next step in its design is the creation of functional examples. Since the first input of insert is any number, we use 5 and use the data definition for List-of-numbers to make up examples for the second input.

First we consider what insert should produce when given a number and '(). According to insert’s purpose statement, the output must be a list, it must contain all numbers from the second input, and it must contain the first argument. This suggests the following:

(check-expect (insert 5 '()) (list 5))

Second, we use a non-empty list of just one item:
(check-expect (insert 5 (list 6)) (list 6 5))
(check-expect (insert 5 (list 4)) (list 5 4))
The reasoning of why these are the expected results is just like before. For one, the result must contain all numbers from the second list and the extra number. For two, the result must be sorted.

Finally, let’s create an example with a list that contains more than one item. Indeed, we can derive such an example from the examples for sort> and especially from our analysis of the second cond clause. From there, we know that sort> works only if 12 is inserted into (list 20 -5) at its proper place:
(check-expect (insert 12 (list 20 -5))
              (list 20 12 -5))
That is, insert is given a second list and it is sorted in descending order.

Note what the development of examples teaches us. The insert function has to find the first number that is smaller than the given n. When there is no such number, the function eventually reaches the end of the list and it must add n to the end. Now, before we move on to the template, you should work out some additional examples. To do so, you may wish to use the supplementary examples for sort>.

In contrast to sort>, the function insert consumes two inputs. Since we know that the first one is a number and atomic, we can focus on the second argument—the list of numbers—for the template development:
(define (insert n alon)
    [(empty? alon) ...]
    [else (... (first alon) ...
           ... (insert n (rest alon)) ...)]))
The only difference between this template and the one for sort> is that this one needs to take into account the additional argument n.

To fill the gaps in the template of insert, we again proceed on a case-by-case basis. The first case concerns the empty list. According to the first example, (list n) is the expression needed in the first cond clause because it constructs a sorted list from n and alon.

The second case is more complicated than the first, and so we follow the questions from figure 53:
  1. (first alon) is the first number on alon;

  2. (rest alon) is the rest of alon and, like alon, it is sorted in descending order; and

  3. (insert n (rest alon)) produces a sorted list from n and the numbers on (rest alon).

The problem is how to combine these pieces of data to get the final answer.

Let’s work through some examples to make all this concrete:

(insert 7 (list 6 5 4))

Here n is 7 and larger than any of the numbers in the second input. We know so by just looking at the first item of the list. It is 6, but because the list is sorted all other numbers on the list are even smaller than 6. Hence it suffices if we just cons 7 onto (list 6 5 4).

In contrast, when the application is something like

(insert 0 (list 6 2 1 -1))

n must indeed be inserted into the rest of the list. More concretely, (first alon) is 6; (rest alon) is (list 2 1 -1); and (insert n (rest alon)) produces (list 2 1 0 -1) according to the purpose statement. By adding 6 back onto that last list, we get the desired answer for (insert 0 (list 6 2 1 -1)).

To get a complete function definition, we must generalize these examples. The case analysis suggests a nested conditional that determines whether n is larger than (or equal to) (first alon):
  • If so, all the items in alon are smaller than n because alon is already sorted. The answer in that case is (cons n alon).

  • If, however, n is smaller than (first alon), then the function has not yet found the proper place to insert n into alon. The first item of the result must be (first alon) and n must be inserted into (rest alon). The final result in this case is

    (cons (first alon) (insert n (rest alon)))

    because this list contains n and all items of alon in sorted order—which is what we need.

The translation of this discussion into BSL+ calls for an if expression for such cases. The condition is (>= n (first alon)), and the expressions for the two branches have been formulated.

Figure 72 contains the complete sort program. Copy it into the definitions area of DrRacket, add the test cases back in, and test the program. All tests should pass now, and they should cover all expressions.

Terminology This particular program for sorting is known as insertion sort in the programming literature. Later we will study alternative ways to sort lists, using an entirely different design strategy.

; List-of-numbers -> List-of-numbers
; produces a sorted version of l
(define (sort> l)
    [(empty? l) '()]
    [(cons? l) (insert (first l) (sort> (rest l)))]))
; Number List-of-numbers -> List-of-numbers
; inserts n into the sorted list of numbers l
(define (insert n l)
    [(empty? l) (cons n '())]
    [else (if (>= n (first l))
              (cons n l)
              (cons (first l) (insert n (rest l))))]))

Figure 72: Sorting lists of numbers

Exercise 186. Take a second look at Intermezzo 1: Beginning Student Language, the intermezzo that presents BSL and its ways of formulating tests. One of the latter is check-satisfied, which determines whether an expression satisfies a certain property. Use sorted>? from exercise 145 to reformulate the tests for sort> with check-satisfied.

Now consider this function definition:
; List-of-numbers -> List-of-numbers
; produces a sorted version of l
(define (sort>/bad l)
  (list 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0))
Can you formulate a test case that shows that sort>/bad is not a sorting function? Can you use check-satisfied to formulate this test case?

Notes (1) What may surprise you here is that we define a function to create a test. In the real world, this step is common, and, on occasion, you really need to design functions for tests—with their own tests and all. (2) Formulating tests with check-satisfied is occasionally easier than using check-expect (or other forms), and it is also a bit more general. When the predicate completely describes the relationship between all possible inputs and outputs of a function, computer scientists speak of a specification. Specifying with lambda explains how to specify sort> completely.

Exercise 187. Design a program that sorts lists of game players by score:
(define-struct gp [name score])
; A GamePlayer is a structure:
;    (make-gp String Number)
; interpretation (make-gp p s) represents player p who
; scored a maximum of s points
Hint Formulate a function that compares two elements of GamePlayer.

Exercise 188. Design a program that sorts lists of emails by date:
(define-struct email [from date message])
; An Email Message is a structure:
;   (make-email String Number String)
; interpretation (make-email f d m) represents text m
; sent by f, d seconds after the beginning of time
Also develop a program that sorts lists of email messages by name. To compare two strings alphabetically, use the string<? primitive.

Exercise 189. Here is the function search:
; Number List-of-numbers -> Boolean
(define (search n alon)
    [(empty? alon) #false]
    [else (or (= (first alon) n)
              (search n (rest alon)))]))
It determines whether some number occurs in a list of numbers. The function may have to traverse the entire list to find out that the number of interest isn’t contained in the list.

Develop the function search-sorted, which determines whether a number occurs in a sorted list of numbers. The function must take advantage of the fact that the list is sorted.

Exercise 190. Design the prefixes function, which consumes a list of 1Strings and produces the list of all prefixes. A list p is a prefix of l if p and l are the same up through all items in p. For example, (list "a" "b" "c") is a prefix of itself and (list "a" "b" "c" "d").

Design the function suffixes, which consumes a list of 1Strings and produces all suffixes. A list s is a suffix of l if s and l are the same from the end, up through all items in s. For example, (list "b" "c" "d") is a suffix of itself and (list "a" "b" "c" "d").

11.4 Auxiliary Functions that Generalize

On occasion an auxiliary function is not just a small helper function but a solution to a more general problem. Such auxiliaries are needed when a problem statement is too narrow. As programmers work through the steps of the design recipe, they may discover that the “natural” solution is wrong. An analysis of this broken solution may suggest a slightly different, but more general, problem statement, as well as a simple way of using the solution to the general problem for the original one.

We illustrate this idea with a solution to the following problem:Paul C. Fisher suggested this problem.

Sample Problem Design a function that adds a polygon to a given scene.

Just in case you don’t recall your basic geometry (domain) knowledge, we add a (simplistic) definition of polygon:

A polygon is a planar figure with at least three points (not on a straight line) connected by three straight sides.

One natural data representation for a polygon is thus a list of Posns. For example, the following two definitions
(define triangle-p
    (make-posn 20 10)
    (make-posn 20 20)
    (make-posn 30 20)))


(define square-p
    (make-posn 10 10)
    (make-posn 20 10)
    (make-posn 20 20)
    (make-posn 10 20)))
introduce a triangle and a square, just as the names say. Now you may wonder how to interpret '() or (list (make-posn 30 40)) as polygons, and the answer is that they do not describe polygons. Because a polygon consists of at least three points, a good data representation of polygons is the collection of lists with at least three Posns.

Following the development of the data definition for non-empty lists of temperatures (NEList-of-temperatures, in Non-empty Lists), formulating a data representation for polygons is straightforward:
; A Polygon is one of:
;  (list Posn Posn Posn)
;  (cons Posn Polygon)
The first clause says that a list of three Posns is a Polygon, and the second clause says that consing a Posn onto some existing Polygon creates another one. Since this data definition is the very first to use list in one of its clauses, we spell it out with cons just to make sure you see this conversion from an abbreviation to long-hand in this context:
; a Polygon is one of:
;  (cons Posn (cons Posn (cons Posn '())))
;  (cons Posn Polygon)

The point is that a naively chosen data representation—plain lists of Posns—may not properly represent the intended information. Revising the data definition during an initial exploration is normal; indeed, on occasion such revisions become necessary during the rest of the design process. As long as you stick to a systematic approach, though, changes to the data definition can naturally be propagated through the rest of the design.

The second step calls for the signature, purpose statement, and header of the function. Since the problem statement mentions just one task and no other task is implied, we start with one function:
; a plain background image
(define MT (empty-scene 50 50))
; Image Polygon -> Image
; renders the given polygon p into img
(define (render-poly img p)
The additional definition of MT is called for because it simplifies the formulation of examples.

For the first example, we use the above-mentioned triangle. A quick look in the 2htdp/image library suggests scene+line is the function needed to render the three lines for a triangle:
  (render-poly MT triangle-p)
      (scene+line MT 20 10 20 20 "red")
      20 20 30 20 "red")
    30 20 20 10 "red"))
The innermostOf course, we experimented in DrRacket’s interactions area to get this expression right. scene+line renders the line from the first to the second Posn; the middle one uses the second and third Posn; and the outermost scene+line connects the third and the first Posn.

Given that the first and smallest polygon is a triangle, then a rectangle or a square suggests itself as the second example. We use square-p:
  (render-poly MT square-p)
        (scene+line MT 10 10 20 10 "red")
        20 10 20 20 "red")
      20 20 10 20 "red")
    10 20 10 10 "red"))
A square is just one more point than a triangle, and it is easy to render. You may also wish to draw these shapes on a piece of graph paper.

The construction of the template poses a challenge. Specifically, the first and the second questions of figure 52 ask whether the data definition differentiates distinct subsets and how to distinguish among them. While the data definition clearly sets apart triangles from all other polygons in the first clause, it is not immediately clear how to differentiate the two. Both clauses describe lists of Posns. The first describes lists of three Posns, while the second one describes lists of Posns that have at least four items. Thus one alternative is to ask whether the given polygon is three items long:

(= (length p) 3)

Using the long-hand version of the first clause, that is,

(cons Posn (cons Posn (cons Posn '())))

suggests a second way to formulate the first condition, namely, checking whether the given Polygon is empty after using three rest functions:

(empty? (rest (rest (rest p))))

Since all Polygons consist of at least three Posns, using rest three times is legal. Unlike length, rest is a primitive, easy-to-understand operation with a clear operational meaning. It selects the second field in a cons structure and that is all it does.

It is truly better to formulate conditions in terms of built-in predicates and selectors than your own (recursive) functions. See Intermezzo 5: The Cost of Computation for an explanation.

The rest of the questions in figure 52 have direct answers, and thus we get this template:
(define (render-poly img p)
    [(empty? (rest (rest (rest p))))
     (... (first p) ... img ...
      ... (second p) ...
      ... (third p) ...)]
    [else (... (first p) ...
           ... (render-poly img (rest p)) ...)]))
Because p describes a triangle in the first clause, it must consist of exactly three Posns, which are extracted via first, second, and third. In the second clause, p consists of a Posn and a Polygon, justifying (first p) and (rest p). The former extracts a Posn from p, the latter a Polygon. We therefore add a self-referential function call around it; we must also keep in mind that dealing with (first p) in this clause and the three Posns in the first clause may demand the design of an auxiliary function.

Now we are ready to focus on the function definition, dealing with one clause at a time. The first clause concerns triangles, which suggests a straightforward answer. Specifically, there are three Posns and render-poly should connect the three in an empty scene of 50 by 50 pixels. Given that Posn is a separate data definition, we get an obvious wish-list entry:
; Image Posn Posn -> Image
; draws a red line from Posn p to Posn q into im
(define (render-line im p q)
Using this function, the first cond clause in render-poly is this:
    (render-line MT (first p) (second p))
    (second p) (third p))
  (third p) (first p))
This expression obviously renders the given Polygon p as a triangle by drawing a line from the first to the second, the second to the third, and the third to the first Posn.

The second cond clause is about Polygons that have been extended with one Posn. In the template, we find two expressions, and, following figure 53, we remind ourselves of what these expressions compute:
  1. (first p) extracts the first Posn;

  2. (rest p) extracts the Polygon from p; and

  3. (render-poly img (rest p)) renders (rest p), which is what the purpose statement of the function says.

The question is how to use these pieces to render the given Polygon p.

One idea that may come to mind is that (rest p) consists of at least three Posns. It is therefore possible to extract at least one Posn from this embedded Polygon and to connect (first p) with this additional point. Here is what this idea looks like with BSL+ code:
(render-line (render-poly MT (rest p)) (first p)
             (second p))
As mentioned, the highlighted sub-expression renders the embedded Polygon in an empty 50 by 50 scene. The use of render-line adds one line to this scene, from the first to the second Posn of p.

Our analysis suggests a rather natural, complete function definition: